Who do you give credit, Floyd or Pac beating Marquez?

[gqjohnb]

Neither one of them get a ton of credit because I don't think pac beat marquez and Floyd fighting him at WW wasn't that big but it just proved that Floyd is back and hasn't lost that sharpness in the ring. To me the marquez fight was just a way to hype up a pac fight by beating a guy who challenged pac and also show how good he still is. Although it was a pretty good fight for May to have just coming back after a two year layoff so i'll say some credit to floyd and no credit to pac In my humble opinion.

[GoogleMe]

I'll give my credits to Mayweather, as he WON clearly, and I'm still doubtful about Pac's win.

[Bushbaby]

Pacman & Marquez fought on even terms,end of story!!

[gqjohnb]

Pacman & Marquez fought on even terms,end of story!!

Yeah but he said who do we give credit for beating marquez not who do we give credit for fighting marquez and if you don't think pac did beat marquez than how can he get more credit. Like I said this is just my opinion but I thought Marquez won both of those fights. and floyd embarrassed marquez even though credit is diminished because it was at a weight that was uncomfortable for marquez he actually beat him so he gets more credit.

[Bushbaby]

Yeah but you said who do we give credit for beating marquez not who do we give credit for fighting marquez and if you don't think pac did beat marquez than how can he get more credit. Like I said this is just my opinion but I thought Marquez won both of those fights. and floyd embarrassed marquez even though credit is diminished because it was at a weight that was uncomfortable for marquez he actually beat him so he gets more credit.

I didn't say anything,but since we press on I'll clarify,Pacman fought Marquez on even terms,fact!!Most agree that the knockdown was the determining factor in Pacman's victory!!The welterweight floyd didn't make weight,didn't try to & while he won every round,fact is he was supposed to!!90% of fight fans that went for Marquez knew he wouldn't win!!Mosley was at 147,floyd didn't & doesn't want it!!A welterweight will never get respect from the majority of fight fans by beating a great fighter who was never proven above 135,when he doesn't fight welterweights,capish!!

[MIP4P1]

Mayweather actually beat Marquez.

Pacquiao, despite having a weight, size, age, reach, power, and speed advantage over Marquez arguably lost both fights against him.



P4P ? LOL , Pacquiao got whooped by the smaller man. Outboxed, outlanded, and then Pac ran up in weight to fight shot weight drained leftovers.

[Pullcounter]

jmm had not business being in the ring against at pbf who weighed around 160 lbs.

[MIP4P1]

I voted for Floyd beating Marquez, you know why? Because he was the only one that actually beat Marquez. Why would I give Pacquiao more credit if all he did was get a draw and a controversial SD where he was outlanded and many thought he lost?

Mayweather dominated Marquez.

Exactly, it makes no sense!

Pacquiao got his ass WHOOPED by Morales. Then Raheem dominated Morales winning every round. Did he get any credit, nope!

Then Pacquiao rematches Morales a year later after he's all washed up and forced to drain back down to 130. He goes life and death and wins on a late TKO due to Morales being exhausted, suddenly he's in the p4p top 3. LOL

Pacquiao gets his ass tagged all night by JMM, barely gets a lucky draw, then 4 years later after he's supposed to be new and improved gets his ass outboxed AGAIN. Mayweather completely dominated Marquez and people are ****** enough to vote Pacquiao's robbery was more impressive, LOL

[dans]

Exactly, it makes no sense!

Pacquiao got his ass WHOOPED by Morales. Then Raheem dominated Morales winning every round. Did he get any credit, nope!

Then Pacquiao rematches Morales a year later after he's all washed up and forced to drain back down to 130. He goes life and death and wins on a late TKO due to Morales being exhausted, suddenly he's in the p4p top 3. LOL

Pacquiao gets his ass tagged all night by JMM, barely gets a lucky draw, then 4 years later after he's supposed to be new and improved gets his ass outboxed AGAIN. Mayweather completely dominated Marquez and people are ****** enough to vote Pacquiao's robbery was more impressive, LOL

I'm glad I made my point because I looked at the poll results and said 'Huh'?

I don't care what weight it was at, you can't say Pacquiao deserves more credit, because his win is debatable.

[gqjohnb]

jmm had not business being in the ring against at pbf who weighed around 160 lbs.

here we go again with the floyd was a 5'8 160 lbs. man when he's never weighed above 151 in a fight.... I guess its just debateable because there was no unofficial weigh in but it starts getting irritating when you pull out numbers and act like they're fact.