Who do you give credit, Floyd or Pac beating Marquez?

[Sumakwel]

Pac fought Marquez at 126 for the Lineal/IBF/WBA/Ring unification bout. Pac fought Marquez at 130 for the WBC/Ring/Lineal crown.

Floyd fought and beat Marquez by a wide margin. The problem is that it was at Welterweight and Floyd weigh in at 146 while Marquez was at 142. Worst case scenario, Mayweather didn't make the weight against a Featherweight turned Lightweight just a year ago

Who would you rather give credit to?

[Sonic Flood]

I'd give Pac credit not because it's controversial but he fought at Marquez best weight.

Floyd never made the weight at a catchweight. Not a single person gave Floyd credit except his fans

[bojangles1987]

Come on is this a serious question? Now there will be 30 pages of posts having nothing to do with this topic comparing the Oscars and Hattons those two fought, with plenty of immature insults to go with it.

[Spray_resistant]

2 FSWs fight regardless of who you think won both deserve credit not same when a blown up SFW fights a WW.

[strugler]

Clearly mayweather..............it aint even close.............he never won a round.....................LOL

[BEEHOP]

You could argue that Marquez deserved to win both fights against Pac, Mayweather clearly won every round. Weight issues or not, I give Mayweather more credit, no way Pac could do that at ANY weight to Marquez.

[Spray_resistant]

You could argue that Marquez deserved to win both fights against Pac, Mayweather clearly won every round. Weight issues or not, I give Mayweather more credit, no way Pac could do that at ANY weight to Marquez.

Well I can agree with that, he was the one being countered on in the fights with JMM.

[them_apples]

You could argue that Marquez deserved to win both fights against Pac, Mayweather clearly won every round. Weight issues or not, I give Mayweather more credit, no way Pac could do that at ANY weight to Marquez.

Had Pacquiao fought Marquez at 147, i think he would have stopped him cold. The speed difference would have been massive and Marquez foot speed was all but gone.

[BoxingChaos]

Not only did I not give Floyd any credit, I laughed at this ass because he was afraid or unable to knock out the old midget.

[el malo]

Pac fought Marquez at 126 for the Lineal/IBF/WBA/Ring unification bout. Pac fought Marquez at 130 for the WBC/Ring/Lineal crown. Floyd fought and beat Marquez by a wide margin. The problem is that it was at Welterweight and Floyd weigh in at 146 while Marquez was at 142. Worst case scenario, Mayweather didn't make the weight against a Featherweight turned Lightweight just a year ago Who would you rather give credit to?

obviously pac. pac beat jmm at his natural weight. floyd beat jmm while outweighing him by 15 pounds and still couldnt ko him even thou he tried.