Will Mayweather be P4P No 1 if Manny loses?

[Shattered Jaw]

Pac should stay at 1 unless it's an ultra one sided beatdown. I mean 18 months ago could you see Pac fighting Cotto? This is literally like Mayweather going up to fight Abraham/Pavlik at 158 or something.

[Spray_resistant]

By default yes Floyd would be no 1 most likely but who cares the p4p rankings are just works of fiction anyway?

[illmatickid]

as a mayweather fan.. i say no
if cotto beats manny he should be number 1 pound for pound

its only fair

mayweather beat marquez(smaller man) who was number 2

so if cotto beats pacquiao (smaller man) who is number 1, then why shouldnt he be number 1?

[oc9979]

But Mayweather left as number 1. Cotto was never number 1.

so if Joe Calzaghe comes back does he become P4P #2

[alexpz]

I just wonder why ring put Floyd in no.2 rank p4p after his win with JMM. For me I think he should be in rank no.5 after that win.

But in order for him to be in rank 1 p4p he should atleast win another fight with top WW.

[joelab75]

as a mayweather fan.. i say no
if cotto beats manny he should be number 1 pound for pound

its only fair

mayweather beat marquez(smaller man) who was number 2

so if cotto beats pacquiao (smaller man) who is number 1, then why shouldnt he be number 1?

totally agree. if Cotto beat Manny he will be the p4p king. or maybe it only applies to Floyd?

[illmatickid]

totally agree. if Cotto beat Manny he will be the p4p king. or maybe it only applies to Floyd?

yea and if that doesnt happen.. then it only shows how biased those pound 4 pound ratings are... sadly

[jrosales13]

This might sound crazy to some of you guys... But if Cotto beats Pacquiao in a not so convincingly fashion not only IMO should he shoudnt be #1... He should be #3 with Pacquiao only moving down to #2... #1 - Mayweather, #2 Pacquiao, #3 Cotto... Because of his lost to Margarito and his subpar performance against Clottey if he barely beats Pacquiao (who he should K'O IMO) he should be rank #3

If Pac losses to Cotto 'in an not so convincingly fashion' then why should he drop a spot? Pac is in a weightclass he does not belong and does not lose to Cotto convincingly then he should still be #1 right? Why drop cuz you dared to be great?

[joelab75]

If Pac losses to Cotto 'in an not so convincingly fashion' then why should he drop a spot? Pac is in a weightclass he does not belong and does not lose to Cotto convincingly then he should still be #1 right? Why drop cuz you dared to be great?

i dont think it matters. you took the fight, you lose, you drop in the ranking.

[baracuda]

for sure.....he's rated # 2 now beating a lw at ww......he's the most overrated guy right now..