Will Mayweather be P4P No 1 if Manny loses?

[Animalistic 5.0]

Mayweather got the #2 spot by beating a Lightweight at WW and he was not even ranked at the time.

Now tell me how can you deny Cotto the #1 spot if he beats the #1 guy at a 145 catchweight when he is ranked #7 right now and will be the only person with wins over two of the top 10 ranked fighters?

[Doctor_Tenma]

Mayweather got the #2 spot by beating a Lightweight at WW and he was not even ranked at the time.

Now tell me how can you deny Cotto the #1 spot if he beats the #1 guy at a 145 catchweight when he is ranked #7 right now and will be the only person with wins over two of the top 10 ranked fighters?

Cotto should be ranked higher then #7 right now and B-Hop has been too inactive. I don't think I could argue with Cotto being number 1.

[jrosales13]

If Pacquiao loses Mayweather would be one along with Hopkins 2. Cotto would jump to top 5

If Joe Calzaghe comes out of retirement and fights Shane Mosley at 168. Where should Joe be ranked?

[MakeDamnSure]

Hopkins or Mosley would be number 1.

When you retired for almost 2 years and then cherry picked a Lightweight and doesn't even bother making a weight then you're an idiot.

I'd put Mayweather aroynd 7-10. How can you put someone there when his division is the WELTERWEIGHT and he let all the smaller guys move up in that weight. Mayweather is *****

[joelab75]

Cotto will get the credit he deserved if Manny lose. P4P King.
same as Floyd when he beat a powerless, fat JMM.

[AssasinKing]

If Joe Calzaghe comes out of retirement and beats Shane Mosley at 168. Where should Joe be in the P4P list?

Owned

_____

[Ekscape]

This might sound crazy to some of you guys... But if Cotto beats Pacquiao in a not so convincingly fashion not only IMO should he shoudnt be #1... He should be #3 with Pacquiao only moving down to #2... #1 - Mayweather, #2 Pacquiao, #3 Cotto... Because of his lost to Margarito and his subpar performance against Clottey if he barely beats Pacquiao (who he should K'O IMO) he should be rank #3

[INFAMOUZ]

right now he is 2..if pacquaio loses will floyd go up?

YEAH BRO DEFINETLY IF MANNY LOSEGO PACMAN

[alexpz]

yeah he will be.

[Sin City]

he hasn't even done anything to deserve the number two spot.. let alone one since he got back.