Will Mayweather be P4P No 1 if Manny loses?

[MexicanMauler]

well fact is that RING took him DOWN a spot after the clottey victory, Cotto should be above HOpkins bcuz Bhop hasn't done **** lately, anyways, if he beats pacquiao hell be number 2.

Refer to my sig

[AssasinKing]

I think they will move him down to #2...

But they shouldnt....its not like hes lost to some1 where hes the champion in his own division...hes taking a huge step here...one mayweather hasnt even tried to take....may dont deserve it

[oc9979]

Unfortunately it doesnt work that way cotto is no 7 right now n floyd is no 2, undefeated and the former no 1 p4p no way i see a jump from number 7 to number 1 considering pacquiao was a former flyweight...

Double
Standard
Alert

Cotto by beating the #1 won't become #1
but Mayweather beat #2 and became #2

[Kevin Jesus]

Double
Standard
Alert

Cotto by beating the #1 won't become #1
but Mayweather beat #2 and became #2

But Mayweather left as number 1. Cotto was never number 1.

[boxasmash]

Cotto is #1

[jrosales13]

But Mayweather left as number 1. Cotto was never number 1.

If Joe Calzaghe comes out of retirement and beats Shane Mosley at 168. Where should Joe be in the P4P list?

[Doctor_Tenma]

The real question is, should he even be ranked at number 2 on the P4P list? No he shouldn't. The problem is everythings being given to Mayweather and lets say Cotto does beat Pacquiao. Mayweather will be ranked number 1 again having done?? When Mayweather came back, I wanted him to be ranked fairly so that he'd have to work his way up again. My belif was that it would have made him hungrier; motived him. Too bad.

[-EAGLE-]

First Pac has to lose;

second i think Cotto should take his place!

[hi-five]

if pac loses, Cotto and May should be top 1 and 2. I don't care who's no.1. They should fight right after to decide who's no. 1

[Bushidō]

If Pacquiao loses Mayweather would be one along with Hopkins 2. Cotto would jump to top 5