Who is greater all time: Floyd or Usyk?

[IronDanHamza]

When Berto and Guerrero are amongst your best wins, you been into them cherries big.

Neither are amongst Floyd’s top 15 wins of his career, let alone his best.

Berto not even Top 20.

[Haka]

Usyk the best who put on a pair of gloves who is greater ?

[SouthpawRight]

easily beating 5 all time greats Oscar Juan Mosley Saul Manny >>> going life and death with Briedis Buff Guy Joshua Fury

[Pac=Duran]

easily beating 5 all time greats Oscar Juan Mosley Saul Manny >>> going life and death with Briedis Buff Guy Joshua Fury

The devil is in the detail though.

Usyk came up to heavyweight as a small heavy and fought in his opponent's back yard every time, fighting any and every dangerous contender that he could get his hands on. Clearing out 2 weight divisions and becoming undisputed each time.

Floyd in the fights you mentioned there: i) Oscar was old as hell ii) Marquez he dragged up multiple weight divisions iii) Mosley at the very tail end of his career vi) Canelo was intentionally drained as **** and green also v) Manny fight he was taking IV drips so cut tonnes of weight against a guy that started his career at minimum weight lol (he never wanted to fight Pac and basically claimed the Marquez 4 KO as his own, thinking that it was the end of the rivalry)

Floyd never unified, swerved many prime contenders that could have given fans the fights they wanted. Usyk showed real greatness. People's Champ

[SouthpawRight]

The devil is in the detail though.

Usyk came up to heavyweight as a small heavy and fought in his opponent's back yard every time, fighting any and every dangerous contender that he could get his hands on. Clearing out 2 weight divisions and becoming undisputed each time.

Floyd in the fights you mentioned there: i) Oscar was old as hell ii) Marquez he dragged up multiple weight divisions iii) Mosley at the very tail end of his career vi) Canelo was intentionally drained as **** and green also v) Manny fight he was taking IV drips so cut tonnes of weight against a guy that started his career at minimum weight lol (he never wanted to fight Pac and basically claimed the Marquez 4 KO as his own, thinking that it was the end of the rivalry)

Floyd never unified, swerved many prime contenders that could have given fans the fights they wanted. Usyk showed real greatness. People's Champ

Usyk will end his career without having faced one all time great. His top wins being past primes

Floyd was past prime for 4 out of 5 of them when he ran through 5 all time greats easily

Usyk has close ones when facing the best

Floyd was peerless

different level of boxer

Usyk might be top 50 atg

Floyd is in the 11th slot knocking on the door of top 10 just behind Sugar Leonard who’s #10

[SouthpawRight]

People must have forgot how good this uckin Mayweather was

it was considered an accomplishment to take more than 2 clear rounds off of him

Floyd was expected to instantly rematch any opponent who won at least 4 rounds

Everyone knew Floyd was the superior boxer and he was held to the highest standard in boxing history

any other fighter does 7-5 and he’s allowed to outright duck the rematch or it gets postponed for years

[j0zef]

Most fans will say Floyd - the names on his resume are spectacular. The argument against Floyd will always be the asterisks - he always stacked the deck in his favor, catchweights, aging folks out, ring size, mind games, whatever it took - and he was the favorite in virtually all the fights.

Usyk is exact opposite. He's generally been the smaller man in the ring giving up all physical advantages, he never had home court, and can never be accused of ducking anyone.

Floyd has better resume... but I like Usyk's career a lot more. I think we'll grow to appreciate him more and more when he hangs them up.