Comments Thread For: Technical difficulties prevented real-time review of non-knockdown call in Gervonta Davis-Lamont Roach

[HandsofIron]

Team Roach, file an appeal, have it overturned, and get the W.

[Oregonian]

This is just horse manure. Tank also told Roach that he (Roach) was never going to get a decision win. This was during the fight. So Tank knows just like we all do.

In the rematch, Tank will prolly win and this fight will be forgotten.

[Oregonian]

Team Roach, file an appeal, have it overturned, and get the W.

——-
Tank and Al Haymon are the A side, so that’s never going to happen.

[IRONCHINHAGLER]

If you assume that Davis wins the round despite the KD, then I believe under the 10 point must system it is scored 10-10. It’s an oddity, but fighters have won rounds where they were knocked down in, and thats usually how it’s scored....I think

Never seen or heard of a fighter winning a rd after getting knocked down. Unless the said fighter also scored a kd. 10-8 rd period! Best Davis could have done is beat Roach from pillar to post after the kd and get it 10-9/10-10 at best without a kd of Roach.

[DeeMoney]

when u are knocked down its very very usually a 10 8 round just the way boxing operates

Yes, 10-8 in favor of the fighter who scored the knock down. But thats not what he was asking. He was asking what if judge wanted to score the round in favor of the fighter who got knocked down.

This is allowed, and has happened. It is not required to default a round to the fighter who scored the knock down, a judge can score a round for a fighter who was knocked down.

[BirdSong]

Yes, 10-8 in favor of the fighter who scored the knock down. But thats not what he was asking. He was asking what if judge wanted to score the round in favor of the fighter who got knocked down.

This is allowed, and has happened. It is not required to default a round to the fighter who scored the knock down, a judge can score a round for a fighter who was knocked down.

yes they can but it doesnt usually happen becaue first the KD is a point then that KD is counted in the OVERALL assessment of the round so to 'catch up' to the KD in boxing is hard unless u go into kick ass mode and really make it your round like beat the guy around the place

[BirdSong]

I was going there. All his corner did was give him time to recover. They just slapped him on the head and sent him back.

lol so what the hell was tank up to was it a delay thing from the punches that just got him scrambled????

[DeeMoney]

Never seen or heard of a fighter winning a rd after getting knocked down. Unless the said fighter also scored a kd. 10-8 rd period! Best Davis could have done is beat Roach from pillar to post after the kd and get it 10-9/10-10 at best without a kd of Roach.

Pac Mosley round 10. Pac dominated the round, Mosley scored what was deemed a KD (may have been a flash KD or Pac was off balance and pushed). Regardless Mosley scored a KD in the round. One judge scored it 10-9 Mosley, another 10-9 Pac, another 10-10. It happens.

Whats crazy is there is no real enforcement of the rules, whatever they may be with the judges. Judges just make it up as they go, and if you dare question them, they get on their high horse and act as if you dont really understand boxing. Heck, if they add up their rounds wrong, doesnt matter, thats what they stick with.

[DeeMoney]

yes they can but it doesnt usually happen becaue first the KD is a point then that KD is counted in the OVERALL assessment of the round so to 'catch up' to the KD in boxing is hard unless u go into kick ass mode and really make it your round like beat the guy around the place

Pac Mosley Rd 10 is a good example of what I was writing, and a direct answer to your question. Yes, we all know how rounds usually happen, but once again, that wasnt what was being asked.

[BirdSong]

Pac Mosley round 10. Pac dominated the round, Mosley scored what was deemed a KD (may have been a flash KD or Pac was off balance and pushed). Regardless Mosley scored a KD in the round. One judge scored it 10-9 Mosley, another 10-9 Pac, another 10-10. It happens.

Whats crazy is there is no real enforcement of the rules, whatever they may be with the judges. Judges just make it up as they go, and if you dare question them, they get on their high horse and act as if you dont really understand boxing. Heck, if they add up their rounds wrong, doesnt matter, thats what they stick with.

have a read of this

https://www.badlefthook.com/2011/5/12/2167500/pacquaio-vs-mosley-knockdown-kenny-bayless-mistake-replay

"Last Saturday night, Bayless called a knockdown against Manny Pacquiao in the 10th round of Pacquiao's bout with Shane Mosley, when from all angles it was an obvious shove from Mosley that put Pacquiao on the canvas"