Comments Thread For: The misunderstanding of Imane Khelif's past and present

[Elheath]

If only people were so interested in issues that actually affect their lives.

Yeah, you'd think that society should let the issues between biological female athletes and transgender female athletes be resolved among them, but unfortunately it isn't.

I actually am interested in how many of those who are advocating for transgender females to be allowed to compete among biological females are biological female athletes themselves.

[Roberto Vasquez]

Filed by 'boxingscene staff' which means the author isn't willing to stand by their 'work'.

Honestly probably scared of being attacked by morons who suddenly pretend to care about woman's rights.

Don't blame this woman - she is following the rules of the IOC. The IOC is the issue.

I also blame the woman who threw a tantrum (Carini). She had no issue until she got out-skilled by her opponent. And apparently Imane Khelif who supposedly "hits like a man" has only KO'd 6 female opponents out of 51 and has lost 9 times to females too. Basically Carini would probably be facing better boxers who *are* 100% female.

[Theshotyoudontsee]

There are no such thing as "transgender" people regardless. There are men who mutilate themselves and chop their sexual organs off and act like women, and there are women who mutilate themselves and chop their breasts off and act like they are men. They are, sadly, mutilated mentally ill people. Period.

As far as sports go, if a woman is born with more testosterone and has an unfair advantage, that is something that has to be decided by the people running the events. And in a sport where people hit each other and can die from violence, there cannot be any unfair advantage. From what I have read concerning this boxer, she was not allowed to fight in previous events because it was found her body creates testosterone levels of a male due to birth defect. If true, that is no different than allowing a male to beat up on a female.

As others have pointed out, apparently the boxer who quit crying has done similar stuff before. And the boxer who has more testosterone has been beaten by women. So it sounds like a bunch of ado about nothing. That said, if the boxer has male testosterone levels and male power, that boxer should not be allowed to hit women without that advantage. This isn't about winning medals, etc. In boxing people die. Female boxing is honestly atrocious anyway. But if they are going to do it, sorry, no women with dude test. That is a no brainer.

F u c k woke i d i o c y.

[dft313]

Fertility doesn't determine woman, nor chest size or feminine facial structures or the softness of the buttocks or whatever else. Also, to be honest I personally don't give a fudge who decides to self identify as a female or male and LGBT and any other personal preference. However strictly in terms of DNA, should anyone who is naturally born with XY chromosome be considered a biological female or a biological male, in which from a scientific POV my definition is that those with Y is a male and those without Y is a female, regardless of reproduction abilities or ***ual preference or identity. And frankly, if a biological XY self identifies themselves as a female and wants to live their lives as a woman, they should...EXCEPT in terms of sports and physical competition because I believe sports is one area where it should be differentiated between biological gender. That is why if the whole male-female stuff is too crazy these days so scrap that idea and differentiate by the Y chromosome is what I am saying should be done...not by the existence of stick and balls or the hole in the crotch or fertility abilities or ***ual preference or identification.

A transgender female can compete in sports idntifying themselves as a woman in the Y-division. A transgender male can compete in the non-Y division as long as their hormone levels aren't breaking the rules set by doping requirements for that sport. If the transgender male gets disqualified from the non-Y division, it will not be due to being a transgender but due to not following anti-doping policies.

Khalief is a biological female.

Gender as we understand it is a man-made construct.

Our understanding of biological sex, gender, identity is constantly evolving.

But let’s be clear, Khalief happened to land a hard blow on an overwhelmed opponent who had a broken nose. That’s it. Otherwise she’s not a massive puncher.

[Smash]

Y'all are lucky I haven't found another source for boxing news.

.

how does u not finding another source of boxing news make me lucky?

[Smash]

the hint is in the name, its clear,

iman

her family decided to pretend she was a little girl with bow in hair, forced her to go 10 km a day to boxing training knowing that one day she would pay them back with medals and glory and cash for algeria by beating up women and making them famous, its just an epic troll of the entire world by this family, kudos to them

[Smash]

this article has 2350 views wtf

[Theshotyoudontsee]

Khalief is a biological female.

Gender as we understand it is a man-made construct.

Our understanding of biological ***, gender, identity is constantly evolving.

But let’s be clear, Khalief happened to land a hard blow on an overwhelmed opponent who had a broken nose. That’s it. Otherwise she’s not a massive puncher.

Gender is not a "construct". There are men and there are women. There are a certain amount of people born hermaphroditic, with birth defects.

The gender is a construct nonsense is an agenda, created to cause the current generation of youth to accept the next agenda, which will be transhumanism. Ie, implanting technology into their bodies, believing that their consciousness can be transferred into a computer, etc. That isn't a guess either, it is well known.

People who have been led to buy into this "transgender" stuff are to be pitied. They are mentally ill and need mental health care.

[Elheath]

Khalief is a biological female.

But is someone who was born with a Y chromosome in their DNA like the case of Khelif really a biological female like those born without a Y chromosome?

[Smash]

are people quoting medical reports here for this xxy stuff, or xy or whatever or is this more wishy washy makie upie i heard this read a bit of this somewhere forget where, facts are needed not opinions, cold hard facts backed up by professional people and established procedures with named medical people etc, the rest is useless