Comments Thread For: The misunderstanding of Imane Khelif's past and present

[BoxingUpdates]

Forty-six seconds into the first round of their women's boxing match at the 2024 Paris Olympics on Thursday, Italy's Angela Carini abandoned her fight against Algeria's Imane Khelif.
[Click Here To Read More]

[PerfectJab]

Carini didn't want to make a statement but you could tell she was clearly very unhappy with the opponent.
While waiting for the winner to be announced, several times she calls out to her corner 'non è giusto!' - this isn't right!

[Stab Master Arson]

There is no "misunderstanding". "She" should not be allowed to beat up biological women.

[TreD]

Boxingscene trying to justify this nonsense?...

What woman has been born with an XY chromosome?????

Y'all are lucky I haven't found another source for boxing news.

I might just have to take what ESPN gives me. This radical bologna is getting obnoxious... And someone is England now owns this site, hence why all the coverage of British boxers.

Jokers.

[SilverMiles]

Pretty obvious propaganda piece by boxing scene, pretty much a shut-up and look the other way, with slight digs at the IBA to diminish their authority.

[juanpablo]

Boxingscene trying to justify this nonsense?...

What woman has been born with an XY chromosome?????

Y'all are lucky I haven't found another source for boxing news.

I might just have to take what ESPN gives me. This radical bologna is getting obnoxious... And someone is England now owns this site, hence why all the coverage of British boxers.

Jokers.

There are other sources fyi.

[JeBron Lamez]

This... isn't right.

[Moz_boxing]

First of all nothing makes me more sick than seeing the opening ceremony and all this lgbt... bs. it really makea me sick to see where our world is going and how they try to brainwash our future generations.
Here it is not as obvoius and clear as you guys are trying to make it. In my opinion we cant look at the testestorone level of athletes because humans are different and of course the most top athletes have advantages they are born with, this is the same in every sport at the elite level, from different bone tensity to a specifc way tendons are attached or just simply way higher hormone levels. If you are the average joe you are most likely not a elite athlete.

All that said i go with a simple view if she is a born women and this can be proven, than make one last test and make her strip down if she is a women and during puperty no miracle happened and she can give birth to kids than she is a real women not that tran..ny sh..t. Only a women can give birth that simple, i dont give a damn about xy or whatever, if you can give birth and never had a p.nis than you are a women. And look at that girl she even fights like a women, she is weak as hell and the italian women was a little baby her nose was not even damaged, she is just a typical cry baby girl like most in nowadays society a born quitter. feed that algerian women to a 20 year old claressa shields and she will get busted up. She a women and not even a strong one this is definetly no tra.n...ny. Savanah marshal would absolutley manhandle her just by pure strenght advantage

[Clegg]

Filed by 'boxingscene staff' which means the author isn't willing to stand by their 'work'.

[Loque-san]

I've seen many sources now claim that she was born as a woman. If her birth certificate says so, then the controversy needs to stop, even if she looks like a man.

I've read she may have hyperandrogenism, which causes high testosterone levels and it reminded me of the track and field athlete Caster Semenya. Their condition gives them an advantage over normal women, but they can't compete with men at all.