Canelo’s Resume vs Pacquiao’s Resume

[ImDominicanLipz]

CAP!! pac agreed to everything then floyd ignored him until he got KO'd by marquez then all of a sudden, floyd wanted to fight him... yeah, let's not rewrote history.

Are you really this delusional or do you enjoy trolling?

[uppercut510]

I know for a fact that we all can see one thing different, but numbers, quality, suspension, cherrypick and clauses could and tell a story.

Whats your take

[Hustle]

tarver is a lucky bum. He caught Roy off roids. That’s why he’s still not in the hof.



bradley is


pac >> Bradley and Thurman

hopkins entire career really

Winky Wright > Bradley and thurman

[garfios]

Alvarez is atg

Just not that Mayweather level capable of schooling greats and hall of famers

Can you show his greatness in victories and faced competition? Without controversy, and if it was doubts the second fight that showed his greatness.

[garfios]

Whats your take

He's a good boxer without a doubt, not an ATG, the matchmaking is one of the greatest I have ever witnessed. All the HOF he has faced were past their prime, he threw the WBC belt in the garbage can to avoid a younger ggg, he was given a gift against Lara and instead of running it back, he didn't face another technician until he believed in his own hype and got schooled by bivol. For years he has kept the 168 division hostage fighting boxers way lower than his status should demand, Morell jr and benavidez are the most deserving fighters at the weight, and the alphabet soups and canelo's hasn't look their way. So tell me, what's your take? Some examples would help.

[QueensburyRules]

pacquiao by a large margin.

Unlike floyd & canelo, pac didn't get to cherry pick when & where he got to fight all of his best opponents.

Guy hasn't fought in his home country, in almost 20 years.

He fought damn near everybody, usually in their home country or in a neutral site.

Guy's an atg

- - ace!!!

[SouthpawRight]

Can you show his greatness in victories and faced competition? Without controversy, and if it was doubts the second fight that showed his greatness.

Alvarez is shallow end of great

What takes away from his record

Lacks some convincing wins

I had it 114-113 for Trout

Lara fight was a draw

I guess most scored the first two fights for ggg?

not the biggest Alvarez fan. Haven’t watched those two bouts carefully

[IronDanHamza]

Winky Wright > Bradley and thurman

He didn’t fight Bradley when he was 40 or over so Bradley isn’t even in the discussion.

[-Kev-]

As of right now, Pacquiao has more HOF’ers on his resume than Canelo.

Canelo has GGG 3x, Cotto, and Mosley*.

Pacquiao has, Barrera, Morales, Marquez, Cotto, Bradley, Hatton and Mosley*.

*Mosley was old and past prime.

Canelo is also not helping himself by fighting guys coming up 2 weight classes like Charlo, fighting guys like Berlanga (rumored), and ducking Benavidez pretty hardcore.

Lara, Trout, Ryder, Munguia, Plant, Saunders, C. Smith, L. Smith, Kovalev, Jacobs, Rhodes, were all top 10 contenders of his time that he HAD to fight or else critics would’ve accused him of ducking them. That’s just the truth.

To be fair though, there weren’t many HOF fighters Canelo could fight from 154 to 175. He pretty much fought them all. Which HOF fighters did he realistically have available to him? Mayweather? He fought him. Cotto? He fought him. GGG? He fought him 3x. Mosley? He was old and past it but I guess he counts in HOF bracket.

Which other HOF’ers did Canelo have available? Jacobs was a good top 3 opponent but I don’t think he’s getting in. He cleaned out 168 but who knows which one of those guys are HOF bound, likely none, they were all just good contenders.

He fought Bivol who has a shot at the HOF imo, but couldn’t beat him. He hasn’t fought Benavidez who may have a shot at the HOF as long as he stays away from Bivol and Beterbiev.

There aren’t many GREAT fighters left for Canelo to fight. Benavidez, Bivol rematch, and Beterbiev. That’s it. And beating those 3 won’t trump Pacquiao’s resume. Canelo doesn’t really have the opportunity to surpass or even match Pacquiao’s resume.

[gamesworn]

They didn’t fight because Pacquiao didn’t want random testing and was afraid of needles. Let’s not rewrite history.

You really need to get out of NSB delusional world sometimes and realize that it was Floyd who caused the delay of that fight. There are other forums too, youtube, reddit, almost everyone thinks Floyd was the reason, except for few delusional comments you will see like you right now.

Only NSB i see the most delusional comments ever and what not i expect from a BOXING forum.