Why there is only One Heavyweight Champion

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Willow The Wisp
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Feb 2020
    • 4440
    • 2,162
    • 3,176
    • 1,037

    #1

    Why there is only One Heavyweight Champion

    Let's see what kind of posters we have here.

    Some posters here are thinking that "The WBC should strip Fury!!" (For choosing to fight Francis Ngannou next instead of Oleksandr Usyk, I guess).

    While I too pine for the unification of the major title claims and look forward to how Fury and Usyk deal with each other's talents; the historian in me has to ask "Strip him of what?".

    Of course, the WBC is contemplating no such thing, as Fury remains up to date with his mandatory defenses.
    But once upon a time, they threatened to do something similar to Larry Holmes for opting out of meeting another of Don King's fighters (Greg Page) who'd blown his shot by losing to Trevor Berbick on the Holmes-Cooney undercard (Berbick got the shot at Holmes and of course, got beat).
    No tears for ol' Greg though, as King would partner with los Banditos to allow many in his stable to wear one bogus title belt or another, including Page.

    Holmes' bold response was to ****can the WBC belt he'd won and defended 16 times, and he accepted the belt of the fledgling IBF, thereby legitimizing that new organization. With this act, fans of the sport were reminded that the fighters and their FIGHTS matter more than the "who died and left you boss?" style Sanctioning bodies.

    The following is the accepted recording of "The Heavyweight Championship of the world" and is archived as such by nearly all of the world's foremost institutions of learning and research.


    The Title Fury owns - The Lineage :

    Forvanta- Phorbas- Aries- Herakles- Tydeus- Polydeusus- Theseus- Onomastos- Diappos- Komaios- Pythagoras- Tisandros- Praxidamas- Glaucos- Philon- Ikkos- Diognetos- Euthymos- Theagenes- Euthymos- Menalkes- Diagoras- Akousilous- Alkainetos- Kleomachos- Eukles- Demarchos- Phormion- Damoxenidas- Labax- Aristion- Philammon- Asamon- Mys- Satyros- Satyros- Archippos- Kallippos- Kleitomachus- Epitherses- Xenothemius- Agesarchos- Atyanas- Thaliarchos- Nikophon- Demokrates- Melankomas- Herakliedes- Marcus Tullius- Photion- Buck- Stokes- Flanders- Clarkson- Sutton- Figg- Pipes- Taylor- Broughton- Slack- Stevens- Meggs- Millsom- Jachau- Darts- Lyons- Darts- Corcoran- Sellers- Ferns- Johnson- Brian- Mendoza- Jackson- Owen- Bartholomew- Belcher- Pearce- Gully- Cribb- Spring- Cannon- Ward- Crawley- Ward- Burke- Thompson- Caunt- Ward- Caunt- Thompson- Perry- Broome- Paddock- Sayers- Hurst- Mace- King- Wormald- Mace- Coburn- Mace- Allen- Goss- Ryan- Sullivan- Corbett- Fitzsimmons- Jeffries- Hart- Burns- Johnson- Willard- Dempsey- Tunney- Schmelling- Sharkey- Carnera- Bear- Braddock- Louis- Charles- Walcott- Marciano- Patterson- Johansson- Patterson- Liston- Ali- Frazier- Foreman- Ali- L. Spinks- Ali- Holmes- M. Spinks- Tyson- Douglas- Holyfield- Bowe- Holyfield- Moorer- Foreman- Briggs- Lewis- Rachman- Lewis- Klitschko- Fury.



    The Belts that Usyk owns - The Lineage:

    Martin- Joshua- Ruiz- Joshua- Usyk.



    These very different title histories are documented, empirical world history that is endorsed by Sorbonne University, Paris, France; Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, Italy; University of Cambridge, United Kingdom; Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Munich, Germany; The University of Oxford, United Kingdom; Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States, Peking University, Beijing, China, Leiden University, Leiden, Netherlands; University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, California, United States; University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, United States; University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada and Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, United States; and we can all look that up - nobody's "opinion".

    The full Liniage (Fury's title) has met all criteria to become academic History.
    It cannot be reinterpreted or denied.

    There is no "reformation" in the Apostolic line here, and this isn't some 19th century field game. It's the only method of unarmed combat for sport that recorded human history deems as important.

    Therefore.....

    This is no 50/50 split fight my friends.
    Fury’s offer to Usyk was fair. Usyk's team walked away from negotiations and Usyk got dropped hard by underdog Daniel Dubois and by the interpretation of many, got KO'd.

    Usyk can box great, but let's be honest; he's no greater a threat to Tyson Fury than Whyte, Chisora or perhaps, even hard hitting MMA converted boxer Francis Ngannou, for that matter, If I want to stretch it a little.

    This "unification" fight is actually about Usyk challenging the one champion for something real.


    Feel a lot smarter about what the heavyweight title is now?

    You should.

    Because you are!

    To follow will likely include some silly arguments from folks who refuse to be taught; but I have put it out there for those who want to go beyond the blogger headlines to actually understand the sport.

    I do this strictly as favor to the sport.
    But I'll read everyone's responses. All four of them.
  • techliam
    Caneloweight Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Apr 2012
    • 5526
    • 371
    • 23
    • 42,424

    #2
    Nobody disputes that Fury is the lineal heavyweight champion. That’s effectively what you’re saying

    There is somewhat a debate over who the no.1 fighter is (I.e. the best heavyweight), though Fury is probably the clear favourite. The Lineal Championship, by design, doesn’t tell you who the best fighter of the day is, only that a lineage exists to someone who once was. The flaw in the system is that it cannot factor deterioration of a fighters rating over time, until he’s been beaten

    Comment

    • MusoMeanderings
      IDKSAB
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Nov 2018
      • 2113
      • 1,054
      • 1,933
      • 16,415

      #3
      Akousilous was boring to watch.

      Comment

      • Willow The Wisp
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Feb 2020
        • 4440
        • 2,162
        • 3,176
        • 1,037

        #4
        Originally posted by MusoMeanderings
        Akousilous was boring to watch.
        Diagoras of Rhodes, champion of the 79th games of 464 BC, was one of the most celebrated boxing Champions of the ancient world. He was a true “World” Champion of his day, winning not only at the Olympics, but at every other major tournament in the ancient world. He was a 4-time champion at the Isthmian games, and was twice Nemean champion. He travelled throughout the ancient world, and was dominant in all known cultures.

        Once retired, Diagoras became an excellent boxing coach, as his sons Damagetos and Akousilous won the Olympic Pankration and boxing titles, respectively in 448 BC. Another son, Doreous, took up Pankration and became one of the greatest champions in the history of that sport, winning the Olympic title 3 times.

        His eldest son, Akousilous of Rhodes, became the 23rd heavyweight champion of the world in 448 BC. Like his legendary father and two siblings, his skills extended beyond boxing into the less culturally important but equally brutal Pankration, which blended boxing and wrestling in similar fashion to modern Merikan and MMA.

        It is truly unlikely that Akousilous of Rhodes was boring to watch, but I'll try digging up some film of his fights.

        Either way, you're on the right track, because knowing this kind of thing is really the only way to graduate from being merely a "Casual" fan of the sport.

        Comment

        • Marchegiano
          Banned
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Dec 2022
          • 1775
          • 1,034
          • 1,507
          • 0

          #5
          Originally posted by Willow The Wisp

          The Title Fury owns - The Lineage :

          Forvanta- Phorbas- Aries- Herakles- Tydeus- Polydeusus- Theseus- Onomastos- Diappos- Komaios- Pythagoras- Tisandros- Praxidamas- Glaucos- Philon- Ikkos- Diognetos- Euthymos- Theagenes- Euthymos- Menalkes- Diagoras- Akousilous- Alkainetos- Kleomachos- Eukles- Demarchos- Phormion- Damoxenidas- Labax- Aristion- Philammon- Asamon- Mys- Satyros- Satyros- Archippos- Kallippos- Kleitomachus- Epitherses- Xenothemius- Agesarchos- Atyanas- Thaliarchos- Nikophon- Demokrates- Melankomas- Herakliedes- Marcus Tullius- Photion- Buck- Stokes- Flanders- Clarkson- Sutton- Figg- Pipes- Taylor- Broughton- Slack- Stevens- Meggs- Millsom- Jachau- Darts- Lyons- Darts- Corcoran- Sellers- Ferns- Johnson- Brian- Mendoza- Jackson- Owen- Bartholomew- Belcher- Pearce- Gully- Cribb- Spring- Cannon- Ward- Crawley- Ward- Burke- Thompson- Caunt- Ward- Caunt- Thompson- Perry- Broome- Paddock- Sayers- Hurst- Mace- King- Wormald- Mace- Coburn- Mace- Allen- Goss- Ryan- Sullivan- Corbett- Fitzsimmons- Jeffries- Hart- Burns- Johnson- Willard- Dempsey- Tunney- Schmelling- Sharkey- Carnera- Bear- Braddock- Louis- Charles- Walcott- Marciano- Patterson- Johansson- Patterson- Liston- Ali- Frazier- Foreman- Ali- L. Spinks- Ali- Holmes- M. Spinks- Tyson- Douglas- Holyfield- Bowe- Holyfield- Moorer- Foreman- Briggs- Lewis- Rachman- Lewis- Klitschko- Fury.

          There is loads in that post that's funny as ****, but, for me this list got me best.

          What even is a forvanta?

          Aries? Not Apollo? You sure?

          Those names, the ones that aren't made up, ain't even in proper order.


          good stuff.



          Comment

          • MusoMeanderings
            IDKSAB
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Nov 2018
            • 2113
            • 1,054
            • 1,933
            • 16,415

            #6
            Are we talking about ωβç title?

            Comment

            • MusoMeanderings
              IDKSAB
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Nov 2018
              • 2113
              • 1,054
              • 1,933
              • 16,415

              #7
              I remember before the first W b.c. title fight the challenger Oedipus said to the champion Gallus something along the lines of Give me your belt, to which he replied Come and take it.

              It was the first indoor boxing match. Gallus said: Good, we'll fight in the shade.

              Comment

              • MusoMeanderings
                IDKSAB
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Nov 2018
                • 2113
                • 1,054
                • 1,933
                • 16,415

                #8
                Unfortunately, Oedipus pissed hot for milk of the poppy and the fight was cancelled.

                Comment

                • kafkod
                  I am Fanboy. Very Fanboy
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Sep 2013
                  • 24850
                  • 2,203
                  • 1,822
                  • 405,373

                  #9
                  There is no such thing as the lineal heavyweight title and therefore, no such think as a lineal HW champion.

                  There is a lineage of heavyweight champions, of course, which is something entirely different. Both Fury and Usyk are part of that lineage. Neither has any more right than the other to call himself "The Lineal Champion"

                  I keep seeing people say that Wlad Klitschko was the lineal champ - but they can't seem to agree who it was that Wlad beat to win the lineal title - and Fury beat Wlad, so he is now the lineal champ. But even if that is accepted as valid, Fury officially retired and gave up his licence after beating Wlad, and the "lineal title" became "vacant".

                  If a champion vacates his title, he is no longer the champion, correct?

                  Comment

                  • kafkod
                    I am Fanboy. Very Fanboy
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Sep 2013
                    • 24850
                    • 2,203
                    • 1,822
                    • 405,373

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Marchegiano


                    There is loads in that post that's funny as ****, but, for me this list got me best.

                    What even is a forvanta?

                    Aries? Not Apollo? You sure?

                    Those names, the ones that aren't made up, ain't even in proper order.


                    good stuff.


                    That list of his is a work of imaginative fiction, just like the lineal heavyweight title.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP