Why is tank davis on the top ten p4p list?

[famicommander]

inoue has beaten 5 top 5 fighters, tank has beaten none. you cant compare them. also tank has looked pretty weak in fights against mid opposition like cruz and barrios. innoue has never struggled that bad against weak comp.

Just to reiterate, this is Inoue's resume based on TBRB rankings:
#10 Ryoichi Taguchi (future WBA/IBF/Ring light flyweight champion)
#1 Adrian Hernandez (reigning and 2X WBC light flyweight champion)
#1 Omar Narvaez (reigning WBO super flyweight champion, 2 division champion overall)
#8 Kohei Kono (2X WBA super flyweight champion)
#5 Jamie McDonnell (former IBF bantamweight champion)
#5 Juan Carlos Payano (former WBA bantamweight champion)
#6 Emmanuel Rodriguez (reigning IBF bantamweight champion)
#4 Nonito Donaire (unification, reigning WBA bantamweight champion, 4 division champion overall)
#8 Jason Moloney (future WBO bantamweight champion)
#2 Nonito Donaire (unification, lineal title fight, reigning WBC bantamweight champion, 4 division champion overall)
#8 Paul Butler (undisputed unification, reigning and 2X WBO bantamweight champion)
#1 Stephen Fulton (reigning WBC/WBO super bantamweight champion)

12-0 vs opponents ranked in the top 10 of the division he fought them in at the time of the fight
12-0 vs opponents that won at least one world title (not including Regular or interim, full titles only) in their career
7-0 vs top 5 opponents
6-0 vs reigning world titlists
4-0 vs top ranked opponent possible (either #1 ranked or #2 when Inoue was #1 himself)
3-0 in unification fights
4 division world titlist
2 division unified world titlist
1 division lineal champion
1 division undisputed champion

[ShoulderRoll]

inoue has beaten 5 top 5 fighters, tank has beaten none. you cant compare them. also tank has looked pretty weak in fights against mid opposition like cruz and barrios. innoue has never struggled that bad against weak comp.

Inoue’s best wins before Fulton were old man Donaire and old man Narvaez.

[famicommander]

Inoue’s best wins before Fulton were old man Donaire and old man Narvaez.

Inoue's wins, TBRB rankings used
#10 Ryoichi Taguchi (future WBA/IBF/Ring light flyweight champion)
#1 Adrian Hernandez (reigning and 2X WBC light flyweight champion)
#1 Omar Narvaez (reigning WBO super flyweight champion, 2 division champion overall)
#8 Kohei Kono (2X WBA super flyweight champion)
#5 Jamie McDonnell (former IBF bantamweight champion)
#5 Juan Carlos Payano (former WBA bantamweight champion)
#6 Emmanuel Rodriguez (reigning IBF bantamweight champion)
#4 Nonito Donaire (unification, reigning WBA bantamweight champion, 4 division champion overall)
#8 Jason Moloney (future WBO bantamweight champion)
#2 Nonito Donaire (unification, lineal title fight, reigning WBC bantamweight champion, 4 division champion overall)
#8 Paul Butler (undisputed unification, reigning and 2X WBO bantamweight champion)
#1 Stephen Fulton (reigning WBC/WBO super bantamweight champion)

12-0 vs opponents ranked in the top 10 of the division he fought them in at the time of the fight
12-0 vs opponents that won at least one world title (not including Regular or interim, full titles only) in their career
7-0 vs top 5 opponents
6-0 vs reigning world titlists
4-0 vs top ranked opponent possible (either #1 ranked or #2 when Inoue was #1 himself)
3-0 in unification fights
4 division world titlist
2 division unified world titlist
1 division lineal champion
1 division undisputed champion

Go ahead and make the comparison for Tank. You can even pick and choose between TBRB and Ring Magazine rankings, cherry pick the higher rated guys and show us Tank's resume. I dare you.

[ShoulderRoll]

Inoue's wins, TBRB rankings used
#10 Ryoichi Taguchi (future WBA/IBF/Ring light flyweight champion)
#1 Adrian Hernandez (reigning and 2X WBC light flyweight champion)
#1 Omar Narvaez (reigning WBO super flyweight champion, 2 division champion overall)
#8 Kohei Kono (2X WBA super flyweight champion)
#5 Jamie McDonnell (former IBF bantamweight champion)
#5 Juan Carlos Payano (former WBA bantamweight champion)
#6 Emmanuel Rodriguez (reigning IBF bantamweight champion)
#4 Nonito Donaire (unification, reigning WBA bantamweight champion, 4 division champion overall)
#8 Jason Moloney (future WBO bantamweight champion)
#2 Nonito Donaire (unification, lineal title fight, reigning WBC bantamweight champion, 4 division champion overall)
#8 Paul Butler (undisputed unification, reigning and 2X WBO bantamweight champion)
#1 Stephen Fulton (reigning WBC/WBO super bantamweight champion)

12-0 vs opponents ranked in the top 10 of the division he fought them in at the time of the fight
12-0 vs opponents that won at least one world title (not including Regular or interim, full titles only) in their career
7-0 vs top 5 opponents
6-0 vs reigning world titlists
4-0 vs top ranked opponent possible (either #1 ranked or #2 when Inoue was #1 himself)
3-0 in unification fights
4 division world titlist
2 division unified world titlist
1 division lineal champion
1 division undisputed champion

Go ahead and make the comparison for Tank. You can even pick and choose between TBRB and Ring Magazine rankings, cherry pick the higher rated guys and show us Tank's resume. I dare you.

Yeah, before Fulton the two best wins on that list still remain old man Donaire and old man Narvaez.

[famicommander]

Yeah, before Fulton the two best wins on that list still remain old man Donaire and old man Narvaez.

Inoue is 7-0 against top 5 opponents.

Tank is 0-0 against top 5 opponents.

[ShoulderRoll]

Inoue is 7-0 against top 5 opponents.

Tank is 0-0 against top 5 opponents.

Tank’s divisions have been deeper with better competition.

And again…old man Donaire and old man Narvaez remain the best wins on Inoue’s resume prior to Fulton,

[F l i c k e r]

Inoue is 7-0 against top 5 opponents.

Tank is 0-0 against top 5 opponents.

What was Leo Santa Cruz?

[crimsonfalcon07]

What was Leo Santa Cruz?

A super featherweight coming up in weight to get knocked out? He certainly wasn't a ranked lightweight.

Tank has only won two real world titles. The IBF against Jose Pedraza, and the vacant WBA vs Jesus Cuellar, who was coming up in weight AND coming off a loss. Tank fans have got to stop dignifying the WBA's secondary title crap.

You say Narváez and Donaire are Inoue's best wins. Narváez may get in HOF, and Donaire will almost certainly be a first ballot HOF. Meanwhile Tank's best win is a YouTuber. Almost every guy who could be viewed as a resume entry was coming up in weight. I rate Tank highly on eye test, and he's got real power. But his resume is crap. Gamboa, Héctor García, LSC were all coming up a division. Going after Barrios when Josh Taylor was the man? Give me a break.

[MONGOOSE66]

His best win is ryan garcia and he avoided a prime loma chenko in his own weight class. If he had beaten loma then he would be top 3-5. His 2nd best win is pedraza. Tank should not be in the top ten. Below are fighters who should rank above him in no order.

1.bud
2.canelo
3. Bivol
4. Beterbiev
5. Usyk
6. Inoue
7. Fury
8. Jermell charlo
9. Benavidez
10. Haney
11. STEVENSON

I agree but todays boxing aficionados think the Paul brothers belong on the top 10 so………….

[Oracle01]

Santa Cruz fight was at 130.