Why is tank davis on the top ten p4p list?

[Roadblock]

I'm responding to someone's post

lol. I mean what is the reasoning behind what you said,,,,,,,,, Im lol that I had to ask that, I knew you were posting back lol, that's not the why I was asking you about.

[Hustle]

So you don't want him on there because you don't like him as a boxer and/or person?

"he has won titles spanning 3 weight classes while being 5'5" and knocking out majority of them and having the highest accuracy in boxing."


These are your words verbatim. I clearly responded to this.

Nowhere did I say I didnt have him on there. Hes in my top 10, but that's doesn't change the fact that he didn't win real titles at 135 and 140.

I dont do no deflecting bro.


Bud
Inoue
Usyk
Canelo
Jermell
Haney
Bivol
Tank
Shakur
Teofimo

I usually don't put heavyweights. But i did since usyk came from a lower weight

[_Rexy_]

Taguchi fought Inoue before he won his titles, not after. Taguchi was ranked #10 and had not yet won a title when Inoue beat him. After the Inoue fight he went 9-0-1 in his next 10 fights and picked up the Ring, WBA, and IBF light flyweight titles before losing them to Hekkie Budler four years later.

I know, I was stating that Taguchi was recently unified champ, became very successful after the Inoue fight, since the argument was that all of his best wins had been "old men"

[_Rexy_]

"he has won titles spanning 3 weight classes while being 5'5" and knocking out majority of them and having the highest accuracy in boxing."


These are your words verbatim. I clearly responded to this.

Nowhere did I say I didnt have him on there. Hes in my top 10, but that's doesn't change the fact that he didn't win real titles at 135 and 140.

I dont do no deflecting bro.


Bud
Inoue
Usyk
Canelo
Jermell
Haney
Bivol
Tank
Shakur
Teofimo

I usually don't put heavyweights. But i did since usyk came from a lower weight

That's the only reason I put Usyk on my list too. I don't think I'd ever ranked a HW before him, but it didn't feel right to take him off my P4P list when he moved up and became champ

[JakeTheBoxer]

I am still waiting this guy to fight top 5 guy in ANY division.

[ShoulderRoll]

Hernendez was ranked #1 in the division, 29-2-1 and had made six defenses. Taguchi was 18-1-1 and just held the unified titles for four years.

That just speaks to the lack of quality in those divisions. Neither were better fighters than the oldsters Donaire and Narvaez.

Some divisions are just deeper and more stacked than others.

[YGriffith]

P4P lists make zero sense but here's mine:

Bud Inoue

Usyk
Canelo
Jermell
Haney

beterbiev
Teofimo
Shakur
Bivol

The top two are unquestionable, and should be on anyone's list.
3-6 may sound controversial to some, but they are UNDISPUTED champions, so they earned their spot.

The last four are really interchangeable, great fighters who all passed the "eye test", have belts and either unified them and defended, or just showed dominance over other great fighters.

As much as i like tank, he hasn't done anything to be on the p4p list.

[Kzbox]

P4P is just irrelevant pointless bull**** based purely on opinion obv some have more claim to #1 but i doubt you will ever have a list everyone agrees upon nor is it relevant, it’s just a talking point and a reason for debate nothing more.

[jas]

how is haney above tank,

tank is a beast, super skilled and punches super hard

[JakeTheBoxer]

Because he is undefeated black American.

The guy is a proven coward and he fights for secondary belts only.