ATG List, Who's higher...?

[Fulcrum29]

Hopkins for now but Mayweather will most likely go down higher when he retires for good but we'll have to see if he can up his competition level first.

[WhoreUs]

drew brees is too short, injury blah blah. made my life soooo much better cuz I'm a saints fan- born and raised in the n-o.

I'm DYING to get to the playoffs this year cuz I know we're gonna be there.

I think Warner worked out for them, they can keep him. Brees never ever leaving new orleans. he owns the city now, with all the katrina stuff and that first game back in the dome.

reggie looks like a bust though.

new orleans would have been better off trading #2 for more picks and then just picking up maurice jones-drew in the 2nd round.

[catalinul]

They are virtually the same position.

[heat27]

Hopkins......

[D-MiZe]

So if Mayweather beats Pac and Hopkins beats Dawson.

What happens then in terms of each of their rankings?

Who would be higher?

[Doctor_Tenma]

I must say, how could anyone vote for Floyd in this one?

[D-MiZe]

I must say, how could anyone vote for Floyd in this one?

How can anyone vote for Hopkins on this one?



Works both ways.

[Doctor_Tenma]

How can anyone vote for Hopkins on this one?



Works both ways.

You can't even make a case for Mayweather.

[D-MiZe]

You can't even make a case for Mayweather.

The guy has much more talent than Hopkins.

You could also say that Hopkins' biggest win was against a blown up WW. Lets not forget all these other fighters who were blown up?

He lost twice to Jermain Taylor...

[hammerhiem]

So if Mayweather beats Pac and Hopkins beats Dawson.

What happens then in terms of each of their rankings?

Who would be higher?

Stays the same. both are flawed but good wins.

Dawson ain't all that great but he's a Natural LHW

Pac is great but he's not a natural WW

I would make floyd and BHop significant favourites to win those respective fights.