Who is more skilled at their peak, Canelo or Toney?

[AKAcronym]

Canelo

But the haters would also say Gatti was more skilled.

I love how you guys make up these ****** fantasies about what "haters" would say or do regarding Canelo. Nobody in their right ****ing mind would say Gatti is more skilled.

[Zaroku]

Tony was a thug and good at his collection racket.
RJJ had no problems with James Tony.

[SunDiego-]

Toney but Alvarez is not that far behind. The reason I give Toney the edge you might ask? Apparently he put his fat thumb up our very own BS resident boxing parking lot champions booty hole. Alvarez would never be able to match that accomplishment ever

[MONGOOSE66]

Canelo no doubt. Toney was very good but easier to hit clean. As he got older he rarely used his legs. RRJ kinda made him look average.

[TreyShaw]

Canelo no doubt. Toney was very good but easier to hit clean. As he got older he rarely used his legs. RRJ kinda made him look average.

Ofcourse it's Canelo without a doubt.

But again the haters will find every opportunity to discredit him.

[Comanche]

Tony was a thug and good at his collection racket.
RJJ had no problems with James Tony.

RJJ wouldnt have any problems with Canelo either.

[Comanche]

Ofcourse it's Canelo without a doubt.

But again the haters will find every opportunity to discredit him.

What tools does Canelo have that Toney doesnt?

[TreyShaw]

What tools does Canelo have that Toney doesnt?

Easy.

Better head movement, better at cutting off the ring, stronger, better chin, a bit faster with hands, better body puncher, a lot more discipline.

[TreyShaw]

RJJ wouldnt have any problems with Canelo either.

Rjj disagrees with you.

He went on record saying a fight with him and canelo would be a tough one but Ofcourse he believes he'll win.

[Gpabrooklyn]

Tony was a thug and good at his collection racket.
RJJ had no problems with James Tony.

Rjj would have beat the hell outta canelo as well, toney losing to him isn't a bad thing, the closest canelo ever fought to someone of Roy's caliber was a out of prime mayweather, and he lost every round