Comments Thread For: Haney On WBC Lightweight Title Confusion: They Can Say What They Want To Say, It's Still Disputed

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Rodtang
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jun 2021
    • 3310
    • 1,519
    • 1,934
    • 0

    #41
    Originally posted by NachoMan

    Twenty years from now when there are 8 recognized sanctioning bodies in boxing, you will argue that there is no true champion in a division who doesn't hold all eight. The reason why this situation exists at all is because the fans and media not only tolerate it, but validate and promote it.
    Yeah maybe. But the current situation is all Suliman. He's a clown.

    Comment

    • SCEN3RY
      Kingslayer
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Mar 2010
      • 3425
      • 167
      • 156
      • 21,244

      #42
      it's only disputed bc of the wbc. how in the fook can somebody win a franchise belt dedicated to one specific guy? and now the franchise belt is up for grabs like it only takes one victory to earn it. wbc ******. With all the exceptions they make they just had to stand on uneven footing with Loma and exchange his wbc belt for a franchise strap bc he chose to pursue the ibf champ instead of the mandatory. and how can you be a franchise champ without the main strap. Lopez should've been undisputed, he beat Commey for the ibf and then beat the man who won the other 3 belts.

      Comment

      • Rodtang
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Jun 2021
        • 3310
        • 1,519
        • 1,934
        • 0

        #43
        Originally posted by LAchargers373

        Undisputed WBC champs?they definitely were. They didn’t have all the belts. Haney no better than Dillian whyte who was #1 contender and waited much longer then whining ass haney. We get it he earned his mando he the #1 but he didn’t beat no one for the belt he’s not recognized as **** except to his nut hugging fans who want him to be called a champion so badly lol
        Lots of boxers become champion by e-mail these days. Jermall Charlo is in the same position. I'm not saying its right, but it's the fault of the WBC, not Haney. He done everything asked, everything he possibly could to get the divisions top guy and then got shafted. And he payed for it too.So why is he getting a hard time. You see, if he had done what Ryan Garcia has done, by becoming mandatory and ducking the champ, then I get it. But the Champ ducked him. Not only that, his world title was removed and now Haney has it, which means the division is still awaiting its first undisputed in the four belt era.

        Comment

        • Rodtang
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Jun 2021
          • 3310
          • 1,519
          • 1,934
          • 0

          #44
          Originally posted by Greenfield02

          Sure buddy....
          Very sure buddy

          Comment

          • Rodtang
            Undisputed Champion
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Jun 2021
            • 3310
            • 1,519
            • 1,934
            • 0

            #45
            Originally posted by WBC WBA IBF

            The WBC doesn't have a Franchise world champion in every weight class, just like the WBA doesn't have a Super world champion in every weight class.
            But if it is part of undisputed someone must be fighting for the vacant title. Who is franchise at bantamweight?

            Comment

            • Rodtang
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Jun 2021
              • 3310
              • 1,519
              • 1,934
              • 0

              #46
              Originally posted by WBC WBA IBF

              You don't get to invent your own definition of undisputed champion. Every recognized boxing organization agrees that Kambosos is the world champion, therefore he is the undisputed world champion. The WBC, WBA, IBF and WBO all agree he is the champion. There is no dispute. Haney's belt is the same as Tank's belt, a second tier title.
              See before you come out with nonsensical statements, go do some fact checking. If you check the other 3 organizations websites, they all recognise Devin Haney, as the WBC world champion. They don't recognize George Kambosos or Teofimo Lopez before him as the holder of that belt or undisputed champion. You see the problem is that Mauricio took it upon himself to proclaim that franchise title as part of undisputed. At no time did he consult the other 3 organizations. I'm guessing because he knew what the answer would be. They don't accept it. If Kambosos vacates the belts tomorrow, will the WBC order 2 fighters to fight for the vacant franchise title? I think you know as well as I do that they won't. Because it's not a world title. It's a special designation. And its not part of undisputed. That's why Canelo blew it off at 168. And as a result Mauricio said that then he would have to do a mandatory against Yildrim. Canelo said no problem. Because it meant he was not going to be hindered for undisputed. Facts.

              Comment

              • WBC WBA IBF
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Mar 2008
                • 1123
                • 305
                • 0
                • 61,791

                #47
                Originally posted by Rodtang
                If you check the other 3 organizations websites, they all recognise Devin Haney, as the WBC world champion. They don't recognize George Kambosos or Teofimo Lopez before him as the holder of that belt or undisputed champion.
                Nobody is dis*****g that Devin Haney is the WBC world champion. However, the WBC Franchise world champion is ranked above the WBC world champion in the WBC ratings. Kambosos is the WBC's top champoion. Kambosos is recognized by all four orgs as their top champion, therefore he's undisputed. Tank Davis & Devin Haney have second tier belts.

                Comment

                • Rodtang
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jun 2021
                  • 3310
                  • 1,519
                  • 1,934
                  • 0

                  #48
                  Originally posted by WBC WBA IBF

                  Nobody is dis*****g that Devin Haney is the WBC world champion. However, the WBC Franchise world champion is ranked above the WBC world champion in the WBC ratings. Kambosos is the WBC's top champoion. Kambosos is recognized by all four orgs as their top champion, therefore he's undisputed. Tank Davis & Devin Haney have second tier belts.
                  Nobody is dis*****g that the Franchise title is ranked higher than the WBC World champion, in the WBC world rankings. And that Kambosos is indeed the proud owner of that belt. But the dispute is that, that belt is not the world title. Therefore it's not part of the undisputed world chiompionship. If the other 3 organizations recognize that belt as their world title, and if it becomes available to all fighters in all weight classes, then it would be. But they don't. And it isn't. But hey if that ever happens, you can let me know. Although most probably I'll know about it first and be letting you know. Or maybe if the other 3 organizations bring out their franchise titles then we can have an undisputed franchise champ. But they won't. So for now it's the Franchise protection designation. To bypass hard tough mandatories you don't believe you can win, to pad out that career. But hey I enjoy educating people, so if your still struggling, don't worry I won't give up on you.

                  Comment

                  • Rodtang
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jun 2021
                    • 3310
                    • 1,519
                    • 1,934
                    • 0

                    #49
                    Originally posted by WBC WBA IBF

                    Nobody is dis*****g that Devin Haney is the WBC world champion. However, the WBC Franchise world champion is ranked above the WBC world champion in the WBC ratings. Kambosos is the WBC's top champoion. Kambosos is recognized by all four orgs as their top champion, therefore he's undisputed. Tank Davis & Devin Haney have second tier belts.
                    And let's not forget that by the very definition of the word, that its not undisputed. Why? Because we're all dis*****g it. Why is Josh Taylor and Canelo undisputed? Because nobody is dis*****g it. Do they have WBC franchise titles? No they don't. They have WBC world titles. So how can they be of the same stature of George Kambosos, when the WBC belts they have are different? You say the Franchise title is the WBC's top title and part of undisputed. So then are you saying that Josh Taylor and Canelo are not undisputed? You can't have it both ways. And neither can Mauricio Sulieman. Which is why the other 3 organizations don't recognize Kambosos, or Lopez before him as undisputed. Sulieman is talking out of his arse. Because it suits him and f**k what anyone else thinks. And that's why that man is boxings cancer. Josh Taylor is undisputed. Canelo is undisputed. Kambosos isn't. And I have no gripe against Kambosos. I hope he fights the Haney/ Diaz winner next so the division gets its first undisputed of the four belt era. The sport needs it. I like all three fighters and may the best man win. I'm more in favour of Haney and Kambosos, as those 2 are the only 2 Iightweights in out there right now of the top boys, that will truly fight everyone.

                    Comment

                    • Rodtang
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                      • Jun 2021
                      • 3310
                      • 1,519
                      • 1,934
                      • 0

                      #50
                      Originally posted by WBC WBA IBF

                      Nobody is dis*****g that Devin Haney is the WBC world champion. However, the WBC Franchise world champion is ranked above the WBC world champion in the WBC ratings. Kambosos is the WBC's top champoion. Kambosos is recognized by all four orgs as their top champion, therefore he's undisputed. Tank Davis & Devin Haney have second tier belts.
                      I get why you want it to be for undisputed. And it should have been. But Top Rank messed it up by petitioning for the franchise title for Loma. They didn't want Loma to fight Haney, and instead wanted him to fight Lopez. That's fine. But there is a procedure for circumventing that mandatory, which was in place before any damn franchise title existed. They should have filed for an exemption, in order to make an undisputed fight. The WBC would have had no problem with this. But the the winner and new undisputed champion would then immediately have to do the Haney mandatory. Not only that but they would have had the Kambosos mandatory also, meaning that right away a belt would have to be given up. That, and the fact that Top Rank just want no part of Haney for their fighters, had Top Rank pull a **** move in requesting the franchise title to avoid Haney and try to promote the idea that they would have an undisputed champion. They should have just filed for exemption or accepted that Loma had a mandatory obligation, but no, they tried to be sneaky about it and it backfired.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP