Shawn Porter is a Better win than GGG

[Boxing-1013]

How can you do buddy like that?

He started it lol

[TernceBudCharlo]

This is what happens when you fight real compition. This is also what happens when you challenge yourself by fighting champions with greater physical attributes than you.

Canelo is always at a height and reach advantage and he's fighting legitimate champions... Let's get real here.

What happened to GGG when he fought real competition? Shawn Porter is more proven against real competition than GGG ever will be. Shawn fought PRIME KELL, PRIME KEITH, PRIME SPENCE, PRIME DSG, and PRIME UGAS. The only fighter GGG ever fought that even compares to these 5 is Jacobs. I rate Jacobs way worse than Prime Kelly, Keith and Spence, maybe on the same level as DSG and Ugas. At least Shawn fought real killers like those 3 and gave them good fight. And stood in the pocket and traded with EJ. LEt's be real, if Spence was a natural 160 ,do you think GGG would have had the confidence to trade with him?

[IronDanHamza]

Why was Glolovkin a p4p fighter? What did he do to earn it and who did he beat? At least he fought Danny Jacobs and was in an even fight, Shawn fought Keith, prime Kell, Danny Garcia, all who are just as good maybe better than Jacobs and did just as good as G against Jacobs.

I'm not a fan of Golovkin, but he was clearly an elite MW and an elite fighter in general. Despite his relatively weak resume.

He fought a list of solid Top 10 guys and dispatched of them all easily. Something Porter never really did.

Porter is a B level fighter. GGG was an A level fighter.

[TernceBudCharlo]

How do you list Porter wins over Ugas but claim that Gs win over Jacobs was controversial lmao

That's a win equal to G's win over Jacobs. But at least Porter beat Danny Garcia fair and square, something GGG has never done, never clearly beaten a fighter as good as Danny.

[Boxing-1013]

This is what happens when you fight real compition. This is also what happens when you challenge yourself by fighting champions with greater physical attributes than you.

Canelo is always at a height and reach advantage and he's fighting legitimate champions... Let's get real here.

I'll give you my honest opinion of Canelo's last 10 fights man. And I'll do the same for Crawford.

10 JCC Jr - who cares, couldn't even really hurt or KO him
9 and 8 - GGG - lost both
7 - Fielding, weight class up, but weight clause
6 - Jacobs - Good 7-5 win in my book, good win
5 - Kov - good finish, 2 weight classes up, but Kov is shot and it was a short camp for him
4 - Smith - just lost in a similar fashion to Ryder
3 - Yildrim - stay busy fight
2 and 1 - BJS and Plant

2 really impressive wins and finishes.

Out of his last 10, only 3 of those are really clean, very good wins imo. The last 2 being his most impressive.

Canelo has 3 soft wins. 2 losses. 3 really good wins. And 2 'cherry-picks'

Crawford
Postol - great dominant win
His next 8 were all dominant KOs over guys who you would expect him to beat. A string of 8 wins like that in a row, by KO is impressive to me.
Then the KO of Porter, very impressive.

2 very impressive wins. Bookended by 8 dominant wins over good fighters.

[ReggieKray]

What happened to GGG when he fought real competition? Shawn Porter is more proven against real competition than GGG ever will be. Shawn fought PRIME KELL, PRIME KEITH, PRIME SPENCE, PRIME DSG, and PRIME UGAS. The only fighter GGG ever fought that even compares to these 5 is Jacobs. I rate Jacobs way worse than Prime Kelly, Keith and Spence, maybe on the same level as DSG and Ugas. At least Shawn fought real killers like those 3 and gave them good fight. And stood in the pocket and traded with EJ. LEt's be real, if Spence was a natural 160 ,do you think GGG would have had the confidence to trade with him?

All Porter proved is that he sucks. That's why he has 4 Ls you moron.

[TernceBudCharlo]

All Porter proved is that he sucks. That's why he has 4 Ls you moron.

That's what happens when you fight top comp. Explain to me GGG's great resume before he fought Canelo.

[Boxing-1013]

That's what happens when you fight top comp. Explain to me GGG's great resume before he fought Canelo.

GGG's resume then is basically Crawford's right now. A lot of (10+) dominant wins over good pros. No real controversy in 10+ fights like that is extremely impressive. Just compare that run to anyone else in boxing and you'll see that.

[ReggieKray]

I'll give you my honest opinion of Canelo's last 10 fights man. And I'll do the same for Crawford.

10 JCC Jr - who cares, couldn't even really hurt or KO him
9 and 8 - GGG - lost both
7 - Fielding, weight class up, but weight clause
6 - Jacobs - Good 7-5 win in my book, good win
5 - Kov - good finish, 2 weight classes up, but Kov is shot and it was a short camp for him
4 - Smith - just lost in a similar fashion to Ryder
3 - Yildrim - stay busy fight
2 and 1 - BJS and Plant

2 really impressive wins and finishes.

Out of his last 10, only 3 of those are really clean, very good wins imo. The last 2 being his most impressive.

Canelo has 3 soft wins. 2 losses. 3 really good wins. And 2 'cherry-picks'

Crawford
Postol - great dominant win
His next 8 were all dominant KOs over guys who you would expect him to beat. A string of 8 wins like that in a row, by KO is impressive to me.
Then the KO of Porter, very impressive.

2 very impressive wins. Bookended by 8 dominant wins over good fighters.

LOL I like how you leave out names of Crawfords opponents because you know they were straight garbage..Gtfoh

[champion4ever]

No. Porters a solid guy and a double tough sob but he lost most of his big fights and ggg has beat the better fighters.

That is not the point the OP is making. He is talking about resume wise.Compare GGG's resume with Shawn Porter's resume and it is not even close. Name all of the top tier fighters that GGG has fought and then list all of the top tier opponents that Shawn Porter has fought. 'Showtime' Shawn Porter's resume is hands down much better than Golovkin's. It's just that plain and simple.