joe fought more atg's than floyd....

[Dirk Diggler UK]

If you're honest about it, Hopkins even at 43 is the best opponent on either resume.

[baracuda]

Didn't Floyd rematch JLC? JLC won the first fight IMO, Floyd at least did the right thing and rematched.

sure...altho i think jlc beat him in the first ,i agree with the rest......i just stated the controversial thing coz one poster acted like joe's the only one with controversial wins.....

[King Flawless]

sure...altho i think jlc beat him in the first ,i agree with the rest......i just stated the controversial thing coz one poster acted like joe's the only one with controversial wins.....

Reid, that another controversial Calzaghe decision

[WhoreUs]

calzaghe 2 mayweather 0

[baracuda]

If you're honest about it, Hopkins even at 43 is the best opponent on either resume.

was'nt bhop also in the top 10 p4p list when joe fought him?.....i think so but not sure...

[Doctor_Tenma]

ok........bhop and rjj(the version joe fought) >>>>>castillo and chico(the versions that floyd fought).....true or false?.......

False. For one, Calzaghe got a S.D win over B-Hop, some (Including myself) gave that to B-Hop. Where as JLC was considered the best L.W at the time and Floyd was the under dog going against Corrales. Floyd didn't decisively beat JLC but he gave JLC his well deserved rematch and won that fight. However, he completly dominated Corrales. Beating RJJ right now isn't much of an accomplish. Calzaghe's best wins are Kessler and B-Hop.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

was'nt bhop also in the top 10 p4p list when joe fought him?.....i think so but not sure...

Yeah he was like 1 or 2 spots behind him I believe.

[baracuda]

calzaghe 2 mayweather 0

floyd loves his 0.....lol

[WhoreUs]

floyd loves his 0.....lol

0 losses

0 heart

0 balls

[PoetryInMotion]

was rjj suffering from parkinsons when joe fought him?.....no disrespect to the great ali...

Bottom line is they are not the same fighters that got them to ATG status.