joe fought more atg's than floyd....

[baya]

joe beat more all time late's.

[baracuda]

Flase. Are you seriously giving Calzaghe credit for the version of RJJ that he beat?

why not?.....it's not like he was'nt an atg anymore when joe fought him....

[PoetryInMotion]

Floyd has fought more hall of fame fighters then Calzaghe, true or false?

[King Flawless]

why not?.....it's not like he was'nt an atg anymore when joe fought him....

After being KO'd twice, losing to Tarver and unable to KO Tito. That was ATG RJJ. That was RJJ trying to make some paper

[keepthemhandsup]

ok........bhop and rjj(the version joe fought) >>>>>castillo and chico(the versions that floyd fought).....true or false?.......

false (sort of) the jones that fought joe <<<<<<<< the version of castillo and chico that mayweather fought. B hop even though i think is past it still was giving joe problems. castillo was still giving people problems after he fought mayweather and giving mayweather problems in their fight. chico was just a bad style match up for mayweather, sure he had the height and reach but he tries to brawl insted of using that reach.

now about jones, we all know he's past it. prime jones would had tried to kept the fight in the center of the ring insted of trying to fight off the ropes.

[PoetryInMotion]

why not?.....it's not like he was'nt an atg anymore when joe fought him....

Ali is still an ATG to this day. Does that mean that if someone kicks his ass that person deserves full credit? Acording to your logic he does.

[baracuda]

False, of course. Tarver and Johnson dealt with RJJ better than Calzaghe. Calzaghe win over Hopkins is controversial and unwillingly to give rematch

controversial?....so as floyd's win over jlc 1 and hoya...

[King Flawless]

controversial?....so as floyd's win over jlc 1 and hoya...

Floyd have Castillo the immediate rematch, Calzaghe doesn't give rematch

Mayweather over Oscar was controversial

What about Cotto v Mosley/Clottey

[PoetryInMotion]

controversial?....so as floyd's win over jlc 1 and hoya...

Didn't Floyd rematch JLC? JLC won the first fight IMO, Floyd at least did the right thing and rematched.

[baracuda]

Ali is still an ATG to this day. Does that mean that if someone kicks his ass that person deserves full credit? Acording to your logic he does.

was rjj suffering from parkinsons when joe fought him?.....no disrespect to the great ali...