What is the greater win? Duran over Barkley or Pacquiao over Spence?

[Tony Trick-Pony]

If Pac wins, it will be better. Spence is better than Barkley and Pac is older than Duran. I think the size disparity between Duran and Barkley is actually more but well, it's not gonna matter until Pac beats Spence and that's a long shot. If he does though, man, his ATG ranking definitely goes up in my opinion. Spence has already proven himself against top guys. He's no joke and a win over him in his prime with Pac way past his own prime would be tremendous. It would be the best win of his career. But he's gotta do it, first.

[BodyBagz]

Pacquiao's win would be greater

and it would cement his ATG status and legacy as greater than punkass Floydette's

it already is, but it would confirm it even more

Larios, Diaz, Hatton, Shot Clottey, Cotto*, Shot DLH*, Shot Margarito*, Shot Mosley, Algieri*, Shot Rios, Shot Lucas, Shot Broner, HORN, Vargas, Bradley 3x....................................and Thurman



Lame ATG resume

[pasawayako]

Larios, Diaz, Hatton, Shot Clottey, Cotto*, Shot DLH*, Shot Margarito*, Shot Mosley, Algieri*, Shot Rios, Shot Lucas, Shot Broner, HORN, Vargas, Bradley 3x....................................and Thurman



Lame ATG resume

That's why every boxing legends are proclaiming pac as the GOAT. Have u ever wonder why there's no one even mentioning floyd as one of the GOAT?

[Left Hook Tua]

So what sort of 'win' are we talking about for Pacquiao, a real win where he clearly beats his opponent or one of those pretend wins where he gets beaten but he really won because the fight was rigged? What with pactrad talk it's hard to know what 'wins' are being talked about.

Pac actually is the one that gets robbed.

Bradley L was a robbery.

Horn L was a robbery.

The only fights that you can accuse pac of getting favorable scoring is jmm fights..

But tbh those fights were so close it could've gone either way.. not really a robbery..

The floyd fight scoring was very favorable to Floyd too. A lot of those rounds nothing happened. Neither guy did anything to be honest but all those rounds went to floyd.

[Richard G]

Ho hum, not the Horn robbery thing again, thing is Horn surprised everyone with his performance and some could not accept that the hyped up Pacquiao could be beaten by an 'unknown'. Pac didn't do his due diligence and paid the price, note that he has done his DD since that fight, lesson learnt.

[Left Hook Tua]

Ho hum, not the Horn robbery thing again, thing is Horn surprised everyone with his performance and some could not accept that the hyped up Pacquiao could be beaten by an 'unknown'. Pac didn't do his due diligence and paid the price, note that he has done his DD since that fight, lesson learnt.

Lol

horn surprised everyone by not getting ktfo

Doesn't mean horn won

[hugh grant]

Lol

horn surprised everyone by not getting ktfo

Doesn't mean horn won

Pac beat horn more convincing than floyd beat maidana, and imagine if that was in Buenos aires?
But Pac was always favourite in rematches with jmm so people know who really win and was bettter. If there was a 5th fight Pac would be favourite also I betcha

[Pac=Duran]

Which one is the greater win?

Duran decision win over Barkley?

Pacquiao likely ko/tko win over Spence?

Duran 5'7 38 yr. old natural lightweight vs. Barkley 6'1 29 yr. old middleweight with 25-4-0 record.

Pacquiao 5'5 43 yr. old natural featherweight vs. Spence 5'10 31 yr. old welterweight with 27-0 record.

Duran was in his 21st year in boxing.

Pacquiao is in his 26th year in boxing.

Duran didn't even beat Barkley.

[Left Hook Tua]

Pac beat horn more convincing than floyd beat maidana, and imagine if that was in Buenos aires?
But Pac was always favourite in rematches with jmm so people know who really win and was bettter. If there was a 5th fight Pac would be favourite also I betcha

Pac beat horn up worse than he did most of the guys recently.

Horn probably lost a ton of brain cells that fight.


I think jmm knows it too. Only reason to turn down the money for a 5th fight.

[Left Hook Tua]

Duran didn't even beat Barkley.

I had him beating Barkley. Close though.