Calzaghe is a shoe in ATG.

[DonTaseMeBrah]

european ATG.

as for international ATG, not quite brah.

[Johnny Rebel]

Calzaghe is the greatest of all time at SMW. Joe will no doubt be in the hall of fame and a ATG in most people's minds, just not on message boards. On message boards every great fighter seem to be "overrated, a bum, fought nobody, past prime, washed up, shot, glass jaw" etc.

[Rickety Cricket]

Calzaghe is definitely an all-time great

anybody who thinks otherwise is a racist

but what if you are white and don't like calzaghe how is that racist?

[Spray_resistant]

Joe is a great fighter but not an ATG, he won't be remembered in 20 years and that is sad but it is his own fault for not traveling and giving anyone else other than brits much to remember.

[The Hammer]

Joe, for me is outside the top 100 ATG range.

That's because you're very prejudiced against white boxers. You've never posted a single positive comment about one that I've ever seen.

You're opinion of Joe Calzaghe is like a KKK member's opinion of Sugar Ray Robinson, so we can't take it seriously.

[The Hammer]

Calzaghe is definitely an all-time great

anybody who thinks otherwise is a racist

I agree, and "racist" includes self-hating whites.

Joe is the best British fighter of all time, and easily a top 25 ATG.

[deezdominates]

Yeah he fought a lot of his fights at home. So what? He beat Bhop Kessler Roy and the smoke screen Jeff Lacy. He beat two ATG so who did he skip and Why doesnt he deserve retire with the respect of boxing fans everywhere even here in hater heaven?

If he is an ATG you, Joe, and the rest of his fans wouldn't have to proclaim to us that he is.

[Shadows]

I agree, and "racist" includes self-hating whites.

Joe is the best British fighter of all time, and easily a top 25 ATG.

That's a pretty high accolade.

[Frank Martin]

Nah, He wont unless he comes back in the ring and proves it. Beating two old legends wont put him in the ATG list.

[DonTaseMeBrah]

I agree, and "racist" includes self-hating whites.

Joe is the best British fighter of all time, and easily a top 25 ATG.

no wonder people hate your guts & call you a white supremacist. top 25 atg?

He's not even the best fighter out of wales.

Joe Calzaghe couldnt carry Jimmy Wilde's jock strap.