Calzaghe is a shoe in ATG.

[studentofthegam]

Yeah he fought a lot of his fights at home. So what? He beat Bhop Kessler Roy and the smoke screen Jeff Lacy. He beat two ATG so who did he skip and Why doesnt he deserve retire with the respect of boxing fans everywhere even here in hater heaven?

[Easy-E]

Joe, for me is outside the top 100 ATG range.

[Send0]

thread = fail.

[civicvx]

I give Cal his due because he stood infront of Jones Jr. Face to face with his hand down and Jones Jr couldn't even do ****. That's the worst ownage I've seen. Cal is the best....

[MANGLER]

I dunno bout that ****. HOF, he'll get in. ATG? Not so sure.

[-GR -]

I don't get why people fight B-Hop. You win, it's because he's old, if it's close he was robbed and if he won well it's because B-Hop is so good in his 40s!

[loui_ludwig]

Hahahaha, sure he is.

[ji23]

calzaghe in my eyes isn't an atg
hell he shouldnt even make it in hof
but thats just my opinion

[Klitschko2011]

Calzaghe is definitely an all-time great

anybody who thinks otherwise is a racist

[Shadows]

IMO Calzaghe is a HOFer, not an ATG.