Prime Cotto vs Canelo...who wins?

[4truth]

You asked prime. He was unstoppable at 140. It was like watching 22 year old Mike Tyson.

some those he destroyed were in their very first pro fight. there is no way he was going to fight any contenders

[Oracle01]

Do you watch boxing? go look at his performances at 54 they were good to ok nothing spectacular but once he stopped killing himself to make 54 and moved up to 60 and 68 he became a lot more dominant that's fact hence=primed.

I wonder sometimes how many of you guys actually know what your watching.

He boxed much better, was faster, better gas tank, threw more combinations at 154 and 160. 168 is worst version of Canelo. He was in his prime vs Cotto and could not even beat up an old Cotto let alone stop him. Never heard so much garbage about a fighters prime than Canelo. 25 years old and 47 pro fights but apparently still not in his prime. lol.

[MONGOOSE66]

Do you watch boxing? go look at his performances at 54 they were good to ok nothing spectacular but once he stopped killing himself to make 54 and moved up to 60 and 68 he became a lot more dominant that's fact hence=primed.

I wonder sometimes how many of you guys actually know what your watching.

You don’t know what you’re talking about.
160 & 168??? Miguel Cotto? He never fought outside of 154. ******ed kids

[icha]

different sizes at prime, a better question wil be who is the better fighter ?? i think that goes to canelo, considered P4P top 10 for how many years now? a decade maybe ?
https://boxrec.com/wiki/index.php/Th..._Ratings:_2013

[Brother Mouzone]

I was a Cotto guy , Nelo beats him IMHO but it would be close .The last time Cotto was in his prime was the 1st Margarito fight , was never the same after that .

[garfios]

What?? You smoking crack?
Kids say no to drugs

He's right, or did you forgot he used to fight at 155lbs and rehydrate to 170+. His peak is at 160/168.

[garfios]

different sizes at prime, a better question wil be who is the better fighter ?? i think that goes to canelo, considered P4P top 10 for how many years now? a decade maybe ?
https://boxrec.com/wiki/index.php/Th..._Ratings:_2013

Never been a fan of p4p, that ranking has always been a popularity contest. The better question would be: Who beat more and better fighters in their prime without controversy. Not names past their prime.

[MONGOOSE66]

He's right, or did you forgot he used to fight at 155lbs and rehydrate to 170+. His peak is at 160/168.

Huh? He’s always fought in the 154 class. You drinking.

[garfios]

You don’t know what you’re talking about.
160 & 168??? Miguel Cotto? He never fought outside of 154. ******ed kids

Not MC, ginger, he's talking about canelo

[MONGOOSE66]

Not MC, ginger, he's talking about canelo

Prime Cotto was 140, my opinion. Could say 147. Prime Canelo was 154. Two different weight classes.
I love Cotto but we never will know how good he would have been after the cement gloves incident. Was damaged goods after. Never the same. Heart of a lion though.