ATG Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather Jr

[I <3 Boxing]

who is undefeated...thats what i thought *****

[PowerpuG]

who is undefeated...thats what i thought *****

Joe Calzaghe never loss.. are we supposed to rate him higher than Ray?

[JM1]

Who cares if he is adored in the Phillippines..thats a crappy 3rd world country that HAS nothing,

this floyd **** rider cant answer the argument so he resulted to insulting my country. you give a bad name to floyd fans you son of a *****

[JM1]

**** rider is red. ***in *******

[thurrmac]

Ameture losses mean nothing its a point system and you cant fight like how the pros do when your in an ameture fight....when floyd was an ameture PAC was getting KO'ed

The 2nd half of that post...regarding Mannys STORY has NOTHING do do with whos the better fighter. Who cares if he is adored in the Phillippines..thats a crappy 3rd world country that HAS nothing, he is their little hero, but that doesnt mean he is a GREATER fighter than Mayweather...Hatton has an entire country behing him too...so what? Losses come with boxing I agree, but as of now...Mayweather has never been knocked down and has never loss...you cant disregard that.

His post as good...very good....but Pac figthing 3 mexican fighters 5 times doesnt translate to Manny being a GREATER fighter than Mayweather.

Just 2 years ago NOBODY was considering Manny a Greater fighter than Floyd..when Floyd was the Pound for Pound #1..and now Pac beats DLH & Hatton and people are saying he is GREATER?

I like Manny dont get me wrong, but he fights the same style of fighters..

we all know Mayweather would box circles around Manny....

your a fu******king racist... you should be banned...

[studentofthegam]

I tell you what, There aint no way Floyd gets out boxed by Erik Morales. He wouldve killed Barrera. Hes about to beat Juan. And Baldomir is a much better coming out party than Diaz. I find myself now praying that Pac wins so we can remove all doubt.

[PowerpuG]

I tell you what, There aint no way Floyd gets out boxed by Erik Morales. He wouldve killed Barrera. Hes about to beat Juan. And Baldomir is a much better coming out party than Diaz. I find myself now praying that Pac wins so we can remove all doubt.

But the atg list isn't necessarily who was the better boxer.. I'm sure floyd could have beat erik and mab but he didn't that's the thing...

[Pacdbest]

Oscar was Floyds first fight @ 154 (heaviest of his career).. One can make the arguement that if Hatton belongs to Manny then JMM will belong to PBF bc i think he'll beat him easuer than Manny did.. Cotto will not be a tune up for manny.. He's def the betting favorite but it won't be a tune up fight..

It looks like a tune up to me.

[Pacdbest]

I predicted exactly how Pac will beat hatton & DLH. And I'm predicting this Cotto fight will be another Dominant Fashion.

PBF will have a hard time with JMM. JMM has the chance to win here.

I'm Right again!!!

[hammerhiem]

But the atg list isn't necessarily who was the better boxer.. I'm sure floyd could have beat erik and mab but he didn't that's the thing...

Skills and ability come a distant third behind resume and achievements when considering ATG status.

winning a world title in the 40-50's is a greater achivement than winning an alphabvet soup title now, which is why the old timers are still at the top of the lists not because they where more skilled.