ATG Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather Jr

[Pharcyde]

Even if Pacquiao loses to Mayweather, Pacquiao will still be higher in the list of ATG. It's all about the resume and accomplishments.....ATG is not about who is more skilled.

So before the DLH and Hatton fights, everybody with at least one brain cell had Floyd >>>>>> Pac. Pac goes out and beats two guys Floyd already beat, and you are saying that on the strength of that, he'll always be higher than Mayweather.

You are a blind nuthugging fool. Floyd is going to destroy Marquez in less than rounds. Something Pac couldn't do in 24 rounds. Then Floyd will destroy Pac. But hey, at least you'll have Flash Elorde and Pancho Villa. Fool.

[studentofthegam]

Let me show yall some of these "inferior" boxers mayweather beat up on:
Corrales
DLH
Chop Chop
Mitchell
Hatton
Baldomir
Augustus
Castillo
Gatti
Judah
chavez
manfredy
hernandez
N'dou
Now anyone else who had a resume like this would be considered an atg. With the exception of Dlh and Hernandez he fought them at the top of their game. Im just praying for Pac to win so Floyd can whoop that ass. Then their will be no debate.

[DonTaseMeBrah]

Let me show yall some of these "inferior" boxers mayweather beat up on:
Corrales
DLH
Chop Chop
Mitchell
Hatton
Baldomir
Augustus
Castillo
Gatti
Judah
chavez
manfredy
hernandez
N'dou
Now anyone else who had a resume like this would be considered an atg. With the exception of Dlh and Hernandez he fought them at the top of their game. Im just praying for Pac to win so Floyd can whoop that ass. Then their will be no debate.

too bad none of the fighters on your lists are considered great champions & hall of fame caliber with the exception of de la hoya. im sure some of them will get in because they were popular & died or had cancer but from that list the only one who is really a great hall of fame fighter is oscar & even his greatness is questioned.

[El Jesus]

Let me show yall some of these "inferior" boxers mayweather beat up on:
Corrales
DLH
Chop Chop
Mitchell
Hatton
Baldomir
Augustus
Castillo
Gatti
Judah
chavez
manfredy
hernandez
N'dou
Now anyone else who had a resume like this would be considered an atg. With the exception of Dlh and Hernandez he fought them at the top of their game. Im just praying for Pac to win so Floyd can whoop that ass. Then their will be no debate.

Hernandez was still in his prime when he fought him. Hernandez didint get out of his prime for a couple more years after that fight.

[AREALFIGHTER]

have t agree that pac has the better resume and the fact that pac dominated great fighters.

[El Jesus]

The funny thing about this thread is, this is what i consider a period threat. At this period, pac is fresher in peoples minds and you are only as good as your last fight. check back with me in december 09, and well have a semi definitive answer.

ask this question a year ago and the answer would have swayed the other way.

[Pharcyde]

too bad none of the fighters on your lists are considered great champions & hall of fame caliber with the exception of de la hoya. im sure some of them will get in because they were popular & died or had cancer but from that list the only one who is really a great hall of fame fighter is oscar & even his greatness is questioned.

Castillo, Corrales, Hatton, and G. Hernandez weren't great champions?

You know about as much about boxing as the turd-slinging monkey in your sig.

[PowerpuG]

What's pacs 3 best wins? floyds?

[1SILVA]

You guys have got to stop thinking Manny is the greatest fighter of this generation. It is PBF

[strugler]

If youre a boxing purist..............floyd..........if a boxing fan .................PAC.........boxing historian .........i dont know