ATG Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather Jr

[The Gambler1981]

I don't even want to start arguing in this thread because I have stuff to do today. I consider them about equal, having either guy slightly ahead is fine with me but they are at roughly the same spot. Once Pacquiao beats Cotto, which I am thinking he will do he would be ahead by a slight margin but who ends up greater really depens on what both do from this point forward.

[boojee]

also, anyone who have Floyd close to Pac in atg status is also an idiot.

Pac is higher and it's not even close.

anyone who disagree is an idiot.

[MANGLER]

Pac has surpassed him by now.

[trickshot]

Floyd is higher not even close. I got Floyd right behind SRR.

ATG

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3. Henry Armstrong
4. Muhammad Ali

[Jiddu Dali]

Jiddu_Dali... u need to counter this...cuz this post closes this thread

Ameture losses mean nothing its a point system and you cant fight like how the pros do when your in an ameture fight....when floyd was an ameture PAC was getting KO'ed

The 2nd half of that post...regarding Mannys STORY has NOTHING do do with whos the better fighter. Who cares if he is adored in the Phillippines..thats a crappy 3rd world country that HAS nothing, he is their little hero, but that doesnt mean he is a GREATER fighter than Mayweather...Hatton has an entire country behing him too...so what? Losses come with boxing I agree, but as of now...Mayweather has never been knocked down and has never loss...you cant disregard that.

His post as good...very good....but Pac figthing 3 mexican fighters 5 times doesnt translate to Manny being a GREATER fighter than Mayweather.

Just 2 years ago NOBODY was considering Manny a Greater fighter than Floyd..when Floyd was the Pound for Pound #1..and now Pac beats DLH & Hatton and people are saying he is GREATER?

I like Manny dont get me wrong, but he fights the same style of fighters..

we all know Mayweather would box circles around Manny....

[Ray*]

Floyd is higher not even close. I got Floyd right behind SRR.

ATG

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3. Henry Armstrong
4. Muhammad Ali

lol thats a good laugh..

[Pacdbest]

Sorry but i disagree, Yes style makes fight but if Pacman cant get rid of JMM in 2 fights then i wouldnt necessarily give him a chance of beating the people who you just mentioned.

Don't worry about Pac vs SRR & Pep, they're all dead. What Pac can do is beat PBF, Cotto & finally KO JMM to make you happy.

[S.G.]

Don't worry about Pac vs SRR & Pep, they're all dead. What Pac can do is beat PBF, Cotto & finally KO JMM to make you happy.

And if he loses to one of the three (most saliently to Floyd Mayweather)...?

[Jiddu Dali]

losses and draws factor somewhat but just because a guy has losses does not mean much.

there are 100 times more all-time greats that have losses than all-time greats that are undefeated.

you keep talking about pacquiao fighting nobodies in philippines.

he didn't just fight in philippines. he fought in other asian countries as well.

what do you expect? he's an asian fighter.

why hasn't mayweather fought outside the u.s.?

you act like mayweather fought top 10 competition from his 1st pro fight.

no but he was KOed twice and he lost to Moralles....when comparing these 2 fighters head to head you must factor all of the intangibles in....

Floyds Boxing skills from top to bottom > Mannys

Floyd is a more comlete fighter .....Manny just learned to use his right hand 3 years ago

[Jiddu Dali]

pacquiao has fought more fights against future HOFers.

pacquiao has won titles in more weight divisions.

pacquiao has beaten more guys that were on the top 10 p4p list.

pacquiao has won more fights as the underdog.

pacquiao has more lineal titles.

allow me to pose this question....If mayweather ko's marquez and manny gets koed by Cotto...

who would u rate highter?