If Mayweather >'s Marquez will he be #1 P4P Poll?

[Pullcounter]

pbf/pac for the #1 p4p status.

if pac loses, pbf gets it automatically

[Doctor_Tenma]

Did you fail math?

160-147=13
147-135=12

Make a poll then, see how ****** that comparison is. We're talking Floyd, who in my opinion isn't a natural WW and Pavlik, who is a HUGE M.W.

[BattlingNelson]

Make a poll then, see how ****** that comparison is. We're talking Floyd, who in my opinion isn't a natural WW and Pavlik, who is a HUGE M.W.

I already did.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=268686

[DrewWoodside]

I already did.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=268686

I'm pretty sure since boxing uses weight classes, then the only way to compare the two would be exactly by weight. If they are off by a lb then one would have to call it a legitimate comparison.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I already did.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=268686

I'm talking about size here, what I'm saying is, the size difference between JMM/ Mayweather isn't Mayweather/ Pavlik...not even close.

[AssasinKing]

He will defo be from 2-10....fact is jmm is the one going up weights...no matter how long floyd has had a layoff....if it was floyd going to his weight...or even meetin halfway it would of meant a hell of alot more

[BattlingNelson]

I'm talking about size here, what I'm saying is, the size difference between JMM/ Mayweather isn't Mayweather/ Pavlik...not even close.

What is size? Are you talking about height divisions LMAO?

[Doc Holliday]

Don't be mislead by Floyds jibberjabber. He's out to sell a fight here and it sells much better if people thinks it's a battle for p4p supremacy. Joe Average may buy it. Boxing fans will not.

Interesting thought that JMM might rate higher than Floyd even though he loses. I haven't really thought about that, but it would be hard to rank him above Floyd despite him being at a huge weight disadvantage wouldn't it?

I can agree with this statement depending on JMM's performance.

I wouldn't rate Floyd lb 4 lb #1 even if he beat both JMM and Pacquiao. He should be fighting Cotto or Mosley.

A while back I didn't have a problem with catch weights, but now that we've had Pacquiao/Delahoya, and are looking at JMM/May, I think it's getting ridiculous. These little guys are skipping a whole division to make these fights happen, and in the end I don't think it proves much. We as fans should demand that a fighter clean out or at least beat the best fighter in a division before looking to other divisions for opponents. Though I suppose those demands won't make a difference as long as "Joe Average" keeps buying into it.

[BattlingNelson]

I can agree with this statement depending on JMM's performance.

I wouldn't rate Floyd lb 4 lb #1 even if he beat both JMM and Pacquiao. He should be fighting Cotto or Mosley.

A while back I didn't have a problem with catch weights, but now that we've had Pacquiao/Delahoya, and are looking at JMM/May, I think it's getting ridiculous. These little guys are skipping a whole division to make these fights happen, and in the end I don't think it proves much. We as fans should demand that a fighter clean out or at least beat the best fighter in a division before looking to other divisions for opponents. Though I suppose those demands won't make a difference as long as "Joe Average" keeps buying into it.

Floyd would have a good case for being p4p no.1 if he beats Manny. Even if it's at 147 IMO.

[Jone2ts]

No. Mr boat buyer will probably get a spot in the top 5 if he wins, but he wouldn't be #1.

Why not Pac's best wins are Marquez, the only fights where he didn't fight past there prime microwaved fighters and that is still questionable becauuse i know alot of people including myself that feel marquez won both bouts. If Floyd beats him even slightly better he slides past him. This is still a non issue though...Floyd is still P4P king. Bob Arum may as well get the title over Pac being that he controls that man like a slave.