Judge by the Same Standards Who is the BETTER fighter Mayweather or Pacquiao??

[Danny Gunz]

I would love to know what horus knows about boxing other then the fact that "floyd mayweather has 5 linear titles in 3 weight divisions" or whatever the bull****...

It pisses me off that he thinks stuff floyd achieved in past fights will somehow help him.

[aether]

pac is higher than floyd in the atg list. but floyd is more skilled and naturally gifted. that's why floyd would the favorite to win in his weightclass. pacman is different. he did things what people did not think he could do, so now they pretty much got tired of picking againts this flawed fighter.

coming out with a record of 5-1-1 in what many are saying the Golden Era of featherweight is far far greater than floyd ever did in his entire career. FACT

greatness is not based what he "could have" done but what he did, that's why pac's greater than floyd.

[Thread Stealer]

Pacquiao, as of right now, would probably go down higher in the ATG rankings.

Better? I think Mayweather is the better fighter, and will beat Pacquiao if and when they do fight.

[aether]

mayweather > Pac


pac hasnt proved ****

he sure beat the crap out of the dude in your avatar though

[Bushbaby]

floyd has more natural talent than Pacman,more athlethic!!But Pacman is a much more offensive power than floyd,while floyd does better on defense,to be honest I think u could label this fight as the best defensive undefeated fighter,against the best offensive fighter at that point!!Who's better,get em together,lets all find out!!

[aether]

So Basically you saying the only reason Cottto is a tougher fight is because he is bigger than JMM.

But why dont you point out that JMM is better in every boxing catergory than cotto.
why dont you point out that JMM is smarter and has more experience than cotto
why dont you point out that this fight is at a catch weight favorable to JMM.

Size doesnt always wins fights.
Skills win fights
Brains wins fights
Experience wins fights

If sizes always wins fights we wouldn't have fighters winning titles in 3 4,5,and 6 weight classes

Skills have a bigger part to winning fights
than size does.

History proves that!
and JMM has far and above more skills than cotto

marquez is practically climbing up 2 divisions to fight. its a tune up fight. don't know why your denying this

[boxingjunkies]

Pacquiao hands down

My vote goes to Pacquiao hands down. Look at the overall competition of each fighter. Mayweather needs a solid win over Marquez and a win over Cotto or Mosley to even be considered great. I don't even count Pacmans win over DLH a great victory so you can throw out Mayweathers win as well. Both beat Hatton but Pac did it way faster. Castillo beat Mayweather in their first fight, if you haven't seen it I got and will send it to you for review. Judah, Gatti, Chop Chop, Hatton, and DLH were the only decent fighters he's beat in his last 10 fights. Pacmans beat Hatto, DLH, Marquez x 2, Barrera x 2, and Morales x 2, and Diaz. He's smoked 5 future hall of famers and made 2 quit on their stools. End of story...

[Mr. Philadel]

Floyd is the better boxer hands down......anyone sayin' anything other than that has some personal issues to deal with!!!......Pac just developed a right hand.......he's becoming more and more complete.......Floyd on the other hand is ALREADY there!!

[Dynamite Glove]

Can't believe so many voted for Pac

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

he sure beat the crap out of the dude in your avatar though