If Marquez beats Floyd does he dethrone Manny as P4P King?

[ThunderWolf]

Most P4P lists put Donaire above Darchinyan, even if the latter was more active. I think this would also apply, as in lineal title, JMM should beat Pacquiao in order to move up. In the same way that JMM`s stocks increased when Pac wins, Pac`s stocks also increase while JMM wins.

In other words, if JMM beats PBF, it is like Pac beat PBF also. But that is only my opinion.

[Attrib_39]

He has to beat Pacquiao first.


Those who are saying JMM won over Pac 2x are morons... Those who can't take
the game and start sour graping...Its an Opinion!

Pac won over JMM once that's a fact!

[Attrib_39]

Fact:
Pac > JMM (1 game)

If:
JMM > PBF

Then what does that mean?...
Pac > PBF

Even there would be a trilogy to JMM-PAC
and JMM won over PAC. that would even out between PAC and JMM.

JMM proved nothing over beating PBF.

[Palma]

No, cause manny beat marquez twice. so if marquez beats floyd and manny beat marquez then the logical answer is definitely no.

i want to see marquez pacquaio III happen!!

[gonzo2312003]

You're a moron.

Manny wins: Jorge Solis, Old Barrera, Old Morales, Journeyman Diaz, Old Oscar, Overrated Ricky Hatton.

JMM wins: Rocky Juarez, Packy 2, Joel Casamayor, Juan Diaz, Floyd Mayweather.

Not even a contest.

Hatton isnt even on Mayweather's level. JMM beating Floyd would cause the whole boxing community to go upside down. Manny will more than likely go up to avoid JMM and into the hands of Cotto. He's got more to lose against JMM than Cotto. If Cotto beats him then he is still good and can make more money fighting floyd. when floyd beats him then he can go to 140 and retire with money, power and respect while all of us ***** and complain here on Boxing Scene.

[Titing Kabayo]

No.... not unless he beat pacquiao...

[nasty101]

pac's the official #1. unless he is dethroned, jmm could not have it.

[Ray*]

NO.....JMM beating Mayweather should solidify is position at number 2 not put him up there IMO, People seem to treat the Mayweather name like god...Anyone in boxing can lose.

[BennyST]

Of course. Absolutely without a doubt. A small, old guy moving up to beat the undefeated, former P4P king that is much bigger and fresh and the only reason that Pac is No. 1. While people might say that "No, Pac's wins over Oscar and Hatton are big" well, beating the guy that beat those guys earlier and the better versions of them and a guy that is generally considered one of the most skilled ever is a huge accomplishment and one that nothing Pac could do would top. I'm surprised anyone could even think of saying otherwise. Sadly, it won't happen.

[patpat0928]

which people think he actaully lost

the same way that many people, including me, thought castillo won the first fight with floyd. but look pbf is still 39-0, meaning officially he beat castillo on both fights.

in a close fight, people can argue that either fighter won. in the end you cannot call it a robbery, whoever wins. that's the reason they put judges in there.

so, even if jmm beats floyd, pac's still got a win over jmm, thus the p4p no.1 remains with pac.