If Marquez beats Floyd does he dethrone Manny as P4P King?

[BennyST]

Most P4P lists put Donaire above Darchinyan, even if the latter was more active. I think this would also apply, as in lineal title, JMM should beat Pacquiao in order to move up. In the same way that JMM`s stocks increased when Pac wins, Pac`s stocks also increase while JMM wins.

In other words, if JMM beats PBF, it is like Pac beat PBF also. But that is only my opinion.

Huh? Who in their right mind would put Donaire above Darchinyan on their P4P list? Donaire doesn't even get close to cracking the top ten yet whereas Darchinyan is on everyone's top ten.

If Marquez beats Mayweather, it's like Pac did? Really? Ok, that is slightly daft. I don't think I'll even try to figure that one out.

[baracuda]

Huh? Who in their right mind would put Donaire above Darchinyan on their P4P list? Donaire doesn't even get close to cracking the top ten yet whereas Darchinyan is on everyone's top ten.

If Marquez beats Mayweather, it's like Pac did? Really? Ok, that is slightly daft. I don't think I'll even try to figure that one out.

nonito is at # 8 p4p in ring magazine now dude!

[JOM'S]

hey guys look at this article ....

our arguments seemed to be summarized in this article ... lol

what can you say about this?

http://boxingfanatics.com/wpz/2009/05/13/saga-mayweather-jr-targets-marquez-pacquiao-boxing-immortality/

[floydjoy]

marquez is already p4p #1

[Pugilistic™]

If Marquez beat Mayweather he would have to be considered number 1 regardless of Mayweathers inactivity from the ring.

[loui_ludwig]

You're a moron.

Manny wins: Jorge Solis, Old Barrera, Old Morales, Journeyman Diaz, Old Oscar, Overrated Ricky Hatton.

JMM wins and 1 lost: an overrated Rocky Juarez who gets hometown decision and can't beat an old Basrrera, lost by split decision to Packy 2, a shot Joel Casamayor, Juan , Floyd Mayweather who hasn't fight in 1 1/2 years.

Not even a contest.

Fixed that 4 you.

[El Chicano]

hey guys look at this article ....

our arguments seemed to be summarized in this article ... lol

what can you say about this?

http://boxingfanatics.com/wpz/2009/0...g-immortality/

What's the article about, i don't feel like clicking. Copy and paste in here.

[El Chicano]

I can't believe 70 of you all don't think a JMM win over Mayweather would not warrant a #1 P4P rating!

WTF?@?!@*$($R#@(*)@@A!@

In my book, he'd surely surpass Manny in the P4P ratings if he is able to pull the upset off against Gayweather.

[D0WNG0ESFRAZIER]

yahzurrrrrrrrrrrrr

[kmcc505]

I already have Mayweather at 1.