If Marquez beats Floyd does he dethrone Manny as P4P King?

[baracuda]

Yes.

Since manny has been p4p, who has he beaten that Floyd didn't/couldn't?

and who did manny beat whos not way smaller than floyd besides hatton and dlh?....

[El Chicano]

Nope. Considering that he lost to Pacquiao, he would need to beat him in a legendary 3rd fight to determine p4p king.

So if Marquez beats Floyd would you say that Manny and Juan Manuel share the #1 P4P spot? Many would argue that JMM did beat Manny in the rematch and the first fight was in fact a draw. Is a win over the undefeated Mayweather not enough to topple Pacquiao's grip on the top spot?????

[Mike_Dee]

it depends how he beats floyd.

and i'm picking marquez for the win. floyd is going to underestimate him

[patpat0928]

Yes.

Since manny has been p4p, who has he beaten that Floyd didn't/couldn't?

easy, the man you said would be p4p no.1 if marquez beats floyd. and whether we like it or not, pac has an official win over jmm in a very close fight.

[nujabes77]

no, jmm still has to beat pac

tyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

[flotorres]

that's no question homeboy

[sycomantz]

no, jmm still has to beat pac

face it man. with PBF back in the ring. he's the P4P king. not manny

[sycomantz]

easy, the man you said would be p4p no.1 if marquez beats floyd. and whether we like it or not, pac has an official win over jmm in a very close fight.

which people think he actaully lost

[Pullcounter]

pac beat jmm 2x

[El Chicano]

pac beat jmm 2x

Officially they fought to a draw in the first fight, Manny won by a single point (after combining the three judges total scores) in the second fight and Juan Manuel Marquez has won more rounds in each and both fights combined.