If Marquez beats Floyd does he dethrone Manny as P4P King?

[Joe2608]

I voted yes but i meant to press no. Marquez is a good win, but his best times were in lower weight classes. Mayweather is too big and it's a mismatch imo. Also, Pac beat Marquez once already and he also beat Mayweather's last 2 opponents in much more emphatic fashion. So really, a fight between Mayweather and Pac has to happen to determine it, or if Mayweather beats Mosley after Marquez (who is P4P No. 4 at the moment) that could warrent Mayweather going to the top.

[STEELHEAD]

ring will make marquez p4p over pac if he beats floyd.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

i click on a floyd thread and it makes me wanna root for JMM


then i click on a JMM thread, and it makes me wanna root for floyd

[El Chicano]

I don't think so. Floyd is coming back from a long break and Pacquiao beat Hatton and De La hoya.

But Floyd's undefeated and former P4P king prior to his retirement which was only a year & a half. He's bigger than JMM, younger than JMM and appears to be in great shape. There should be no excuses for Floyd when Juan Manuel Marquez whoops that ass.

[MELLY-MEL...]

yeah he would.

[Xyei]

I voted yes but i meant to press no. Marquez is a good win, but his best times were in lower weight classes. Mayweather is too big and it's a mismatch imo. Also, Pac beat Marquez once already and he also beat Mayweather's last 2 opponents in much more emphatic fashion. So really, a fight between Mayweather and Pac has to happen to determine it, or if Mayweather beats Mosley after Marquez (who is P4P No. 4 at the moment) that could warrent Mayweather going to the top.

You didn't understand the question. The question is if Marquez beats Floyd, is Marquez the number one p4p guy?

[MANGLER]

No. He still gotta beat Pac, or Pac would have to lose or look like **** in his next fight for JMM to surpass him. Mr boat buyer ain't on the list now, so he can't claim **** til he beats one of these guys.

[Chase8400]

No!...............You have to beat the man to be the man.

No way you can be ranked higher than the guy who beat you if the resume's are equal. Much like Hopkins will never be considered better than Roy Jones.

[xcaret]

is hatton better than floyd?


so yes.

[Jean28]

Nope. Considering that he lost to Pacquiao, he would need to beat him in a legendary 3rd fight to determine p4p king.