Is Pac NOW the fighter of the decade?

[Left Hook Tua]

Morales was old when pac beat him and pac lost the 1st fight, he got a boxing lesson from Marquez for parts of both fights

First of all Floyd took castillo, the top guy (no david diaz) on in his 1st fight at 135, Hernandez was unbeaten at 130 and floyd won that WBC title at 21 years of age. You can add hatton too, since he was undefeated before he met floyd and many picked floyd to lose that fight.

morales was several years younger than genaro , baldomir , oscar and gatti who floyd got his belts from.

he might have been past prime a bit but obviously still good enough to beat pac 1st time around wasn't he?



castillo was NOT floyd's first fight at lightweight. the majority of floyd's fights at the start of his career was above 130. above 130 is lightweight. most of floyd's 130 fights was after he won the belt when he had to be 130 or under.

and why the hell are you comparing floyd's best win (castillo) to one of manny's tuneup fights (diaz) lol wth?


wow! floyd won the wbc 130 belt at 21? amazing. you do realize that manny won the wbc 112 AND lineal 112 title at 19 right? lol

[Mr. Philadel]

keep talkin'......as a matter of fact make 100 threads a day about how Pac is better or greater than Floyd.....keep tellin' yall selves Manny beats Floyd....go ahead!!!.......there's no way around this fight now.....Manny and Arum are in a corner with no where to run......the public or better yet the WORLD will be callin' for this fight after July 18th .......and when Floyd dusts Manny off......please dont come with that too small **** because you cats are talkin BIG **** about a dude yall say is too small to dance with Floyd.....come on man....logic over hate!!!

[Main Event]

I think we'll find out by the end of the year

[Left Hook Tua]

Pac may be in a position where he could lose to Floyd and still be the FOTD depending on what the fight looked like.

quite possible.

just because floyd beats him doesn't mean what he did before means nothing.

it's a title that isn't passed on from vanquished to victor like a championship belt.

calzaghe beat jones. does that mean calzaghe had the better career and resume?

[Main Event]

Yes, without a doubt.

Don't get me wrong, I give Mayweather credit for his great performance in fantasy matchups. The fact that he would beat Cotto, Margarito, Mosley, Sugar Ray Robinson, Hagler etc. according to bunch of idiots on here...wow, that's impressive.

Crazy as it sounds, I'll go with facts over 'woulda, coulda, shoulda'.

Someone ranked Manny up there with Ali and Robinson last night if we wanna talk about fantasys

[Roger Mellie]

quite possible.

just because floyd beats him doesn't mean what he did before means nothing.

it's a title that isn't passed on from vanquished to victor like a championship belt.

calzaghe beat jones. does that mean calzaghe had the better career and resume?

Thats a good point you make.Its all about opinions this kind of thing,and for me its Pacquiao,but just because I would rather watch him fight,and thats not taking anything away from floyd.They are both magnificent in their own ways and really the only two fighters you should be talking about as far as FOTD goes.

[MANGLER]

Pac's got Mr boat buyer beat on this issue.

[Left Hook Tua]

keep talkin'......as a matter of fact make 100 threads a day about how Pac is better or greater than Floyd.....keep tellin' yall selves Manny beats Floyd....go ahead!!!.......there's no way around this fight now.....Manny and Arum are in a corner with no where to run......the public or better yet the WORLD will be callin' for this fight after July 18th .......and when Floyd dusts Manny off......please dont come with that too small **** because you cats are talkin BIG **** about a dude yall say is too small to dance with Floyd.....come on man....logic over hate!!!

I think we'll find out by the end of the year

talking about fighter of the decade and better career/resume.

say floyd beats manny in their upcoming fight does that automatically mean he has had a better resume/career?

Someone ranked Manny up there with Ali and Robinson last night if we wanna talk about fantasys

ranking someone with other greats is not the same as saying he'd beat them.

[Main Event]

talking about fighter of the decade and better career/resume.

say floyd beats manny in their upcoming fight does that automatically mean he has had a better resume/career?



ranking someone with other greats is not the same as saying he'd beat them.

So you would put Manny in the Top 10 all time?

[Main Event]

talking about fighter of the decade and better career/resume.

say floyd beats manny in their upcoming fight does that automatically mean he has had a better resume/career?

Not saying it does but were talking about fighter of the decadde before last night it was Floyd after last night some feel its Manny why wouldnt you dub the winner of that fight fighter of the decade?

ranking someone with other greats is not the same as saying he'd beat them.

So you would put Manny in the top 10 All time?