Who was the better fighter in your opinion Calzaghe or Tszyu

[The_Demon]

kostya is ranked higher p4p.calzaghe is a great fighter aswell very tough 2 call

[Rich Loc]

How is Kostya the better boxer. Calzaghe has done more.

Yes,Kostya is the better boxer skillwise but not overall.

I guess Floyd Mayweather is better than Pernell

[boxasmash]

about even.

both unified their divisions, zoo may have been a bit more skilled but calzaghe remained undefeated and defended his title 21 times so he just about edges it.

[CiganoBoxer]

How can we even compare the two!? ......Calslappy love him or hate him.. is leagues above Tszyu in any sense of the imagination !
Lets be fair anyone that does compare the two are simply Calzaghe haters!
We shouldnt even mention the two in the same breath lol

[Left Hook Tua]

Vince Phillips is one bad mother ****er, funny how the only people who picked tszyu so far are known calzaghe haters

vince phillips was a very good fighter.

it's well known that kostya had training and diet issues before the phillips fight.

he fixed his training and diet after the loss. looking at what he did afterwards , hard to deny it.

sometimes a loss makes the fighter better.

joe has never loss so we could never tell how he would have handled it.

maybe kostya should have fought 43 yr. olds instead of vince or ricky......

[Left Hook Tua]

about even.

both unified their divisions, zoo may have been a bit more skilled but calzaghe remained undefeated and defended his title 21 times so he just about edges it.

kostya tszyu unified against zab judah and sharmba mitchell.

joe calzaghe did it against jeff lacy and mikkel kessler.

i don't like zab much and sharmba ain't anything special but they are far superior to lacy and kessler.

[Left Hook Tua]

How is Kostya the better boxer. Calzaghe has done more.

didn't you say before that kostya's win over chavez don't mean anything because chavez was old?

yet chavez was in his mid 30's when he fought kostya but joe has done more because his 2 biggest wins came from guys in their 40's?

calzaghe is sorry.

he has a **** resume and you can't even talk about his skills either because the moron looks like an amateur in there.

[KJB]

Calzaghe without a doubt. Kostya is heavily overrated

Nah, Kostya is a real bad ass. Not perfect, but a DAMN good fighter in his day.

[boxasmash]

kostya tszyu unified against zab judah and sharmba mitchell.

joe calzaghe did it against jeff lacy and mikkel kessler.

i don't like zab much and sharmba ain't anything special but they are far superior to lacy and kessler.

kessler, lacy >>>>> judah, mitchell

[Left Hook Tua]

kessler, lacy >>>>> judah, mitchell

wow!

seriously?

please explain.