Who was the better fighter in your opinion Calzaghe or Tszyu

[Rich Loc]

didn't you say before that kostya's win over chavez don't mean anything because chavez was old?

yet chavez was in his mid 30's when he fought kostya but joe has done more because his 2 biggest wins came from guys in their 40's?

calzaghe is sorry.

he has a **** resume and you can't even talk about his skills either because the moron looks like an amateur in there.

Was JCC a P4P fighter when Kostya beat him

[zojo]

kostya tszyu unified against zab judah and sharmba mitchell.

joe calzaghe did it against jeff lacy and mikkel kessler.

i don't like zab much and sharmba ain't anything special but they are far superior to lacy and kessler.

what a joke, who has judah ever beat to make you think hes superior to kessler?
the guy lost to baldomir ffs

kesslers skills>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>judahs

[hookoutofhell]

lacy > judah
kessler > mitchell

i think zaghe is the better fighter p4p i think he has better skills than most people realize, i think he iis very smart and probably the best in ring tactician, his ability to adjust in the ring is second to none. there are other good fighters who are skilled such as hopkins and toney but only JMM is in the same league as calzaghe.

in terms of achievement i see it being alot closer, zoo got himself over to the USA in his prime and showcased his talents a little bit more. zaghe did it later in his career but still managed to get the W against hopkins.

imo its calzaghe.

[Technical_Skill]

what a joke, who has judah ever beat to make you think hes superior to kessler?
the guy lost to baldomir ffs

kesslers skills>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>judahs

Ermm Judah was a P4P fighter and beat cory spinks to become the man at 147 pounds. I think spinks was p4p when Judah beat him too.

How many p4p fighters did kessler beat?

[Rich Loc]

lacy > judah
kessler > mitchell

i think zaghe is the better fighter p4p i think he has better skills than most people realize, i think he iis very smart and probably the best in ring tactician, his ability to adjust in the ring is second to none. there are other good fighters who are skilled such as hopkins and toney but only JMM is in the same league as calzaghe.

in terms of achievement i see it being alot closer, zoo got himself over to the USA in his prime and showcased his talents a little bit more. zaghe did it later in his career but still managed to get the W against hopkins.

imo its calzaghe.

No way is Lacy better than Judah. Just NO

[Rich Loc]

Ermm Judah was a P4P fighter and beat cory spinks to become the man at 147 pounds. I think spinks was p4p when Judah beat him too.

How many p4p fighters did kessler beat?

Mundine............

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

lacy > judah
kessler > mitchell

i think zaghe is the better fighter p4p i think he has better skills than most people realize, i think he iis very smart and probably the best in ring tactician, his ability to adjust in the ring is second to none. there are other good fighters who are skilled such as hopkins and toney but only JMM is in the same league as calzaghe.

in terms of achievement i see it being alot closer, zoo got himself over to the USA in his prime and showcased his talents a little bit more. zaghe did it later in his career but still managed to get the W against hopkins.

imo its calzaghe.

dude, no way is lacy better than zab p4p. zab has beaten better opposition (imo) and is by far the more skilled of the two.

i like lacy but he is a b- champion who was exciting, powerful but limited.

[Left Hook Tua]

Was JCC a P4P fighter when Kostya beat him

was roy?

was kessler?

was lacy?

bernard was 43 yrs. old. 43. no matter how good bernard is. no matter how skilled he is. no matter how smart he is. no matter how highly he was ranked. he was 43.

kostya tszyu was on ring magazine's top 10 p4p list off and on , from #10 to as high as #2 or 3 from 1995 to 2005.

there's a reason joe didn't make the list 'til barely 2 years ago.

who'd he fight to finally get on the list?

mikkell kessler who still hasn't fought anyone , jeff lacy who is nothing , a 43 yr. old former middleweight champion hopkins and a 40 yr. old roy who has been shot for the last 4 years.

[Davros?]

No way is Lacy better than Judah. Just NO

Judah at his best was a better fighter than Lacy imo.

[Left Hook Tua]

what a joke, who has judah ever beat to make you think hes superior to kessler?
the guy lost to baldomir ffs

kesslers skills>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>judahs

okay.

if you say so...... lmfao