Who was the better fighter in your opinion Calzaghe or Tszyu

[Mugwump]

It's difficult for me to split them. They're both ATG.

Style wise they are practically impossible to compare.

[letsgobrady]

Try again Chavez was 38, younger then both Hopkins and Jones, Cal's best wins. That said Chavez was far more war torn then Hopkins, but not Jones.

Tsyzu was the better fighter, better opposition, more skill, power, adjustments, and smarter fighter. More humble. Man the list is long on how Tszyu was a better and far more respected fighter.

better opposition?
adjust better than calzage?
smarter fighter?

i don't know about all that, who has tszyu fought? a chavez that people give oscar **** for beating up, zab judah is a very good win especially at the time but zab did have his hands down and is probably more at fault for that k.o than tszyu and the sharmba fights shouldn't even count tzsyu was throwin sharmba around most of the 1st fight and injured his knee

[letsgobrady]

i think kostya is a great fighter but i don't think his resume is better than calzaghe's and kostya was kinda dirty i'm not to big on dirty fighters

[Pullcounter]

when tszyu fought judah that was a risky fight. calz has never fought a risky fight

[Dirk Diggler UK]

when tszyu fought judah that was a risky fight. calz has never fought a risky fight

I thought you were never gonna post on a Calzaghe thread again

[Sick/]

when tszyu fought judah that was a risky fight. calz has never fought a risky fight

LOL WTF? lay off the drugs homeboy

[RoyJonesJrp4pno1]

Calzaghe is better. He would never lose to fighters the calibre of Hatton and Phillips. His wins against Nard, Lacy, Kessler and Jones is a bigger accomplishment than what Tszyu accomplished IMO.

[Pullcounter]

Calzaghe is better. He would never lose to fighters the calibre of Hatton and Phillips. His wins against Nard, Lacy, Kessler and Jones is a bigger accomplishment than what Tszyu accomplished IMO.

tszyu fought both in his primes. calz fought nard and jones past their primes.

LOL WTF? lay off the drugs homeboy

ditto

I thought you were never gonna post on a Calzaghe thread again

me too

[yeykax]

well tszyu was a more entertaining boxer than SlapZage but he acomplish more than Tszyu!!