Who was the better fighter in your opinion Calzaghe or Tszyu

[Left Hook Tua]

i would say joe..the fact that he hasnt lost..

i can fight my sister 46 times and be 46-0.

don't mean ****.

[Benny Leonard]

sven ottke vs. sugar ray robinson?


all calzaghe fans can talk about is his 0.

that's ALL they have to talk about.



brian nielsen should have retired at 49-0. damn you , ****y ryan!!!!!!

[_LOAD_THE_LEFT_]

Tszyu no doubt. Very skilled fighter. Hatton was around his prime tszyu away his prime. Not much fighters wanted to fight tszyu at his prime.

[ACHlLLES]

i can fight my sister 46 times and be 46-0.

don't mean ****.

All 46 fighters Calzaghe fought would KO your tiny ass out. Even the one you consider the biggest bum on his resume. And even the bums on his resume put are better fighters the most of the people tua fought

[BennyST]

Tszyu was the better fighter, in a pound for pound fight, he would have beaten Calzaghe. Calzaghe has arguably accomplished more though.

I agree. Tszyu was a better fighter and would win in the pound for pound sense. Especially as Calzaghe is a southpaw and Tszyu had a laser for southpaws. But, in the overall scheme Calzaghe is undefeated, two weight world champion and beat the better fighters in Hopkins and Jones Jr (apart from Chavez who was in about the same state as Jones) even though Tszyu actually faced the much better fighters across his career. The names of those two are bigger than the guys Tszyu fought apart from Chavez.

[Left Hook Tua]

All 46 fighters Calzaghe fought would KO your tiny ass out. Even the one you consider the biggest bum on his resume. And even the bums on his resume put are better fighters the most of the people tua fought

i doubt it.

maybe tko.

i can take a shot.



list calzaghe's top 10 biggest fights.

[Left Hook Tua]

I agree. Tszyu was a better fighter and would win in the pound for pound sense. Especially as Calzaghe is a southpaw and Tszyu had a laser for southpaws. But, in the overall scheme Calzaghe is undefeated, two weight world champion and beat the better fighters in Hopkins and Jones Jr (apart from Chavez who was in about the same state as Jones) even though Tszyu actually faced the much better fighters across his career. The names of those two are bigger than the guys Tszyu fought apart from Chavez.

too bad kostya wasn't with warren.

he could have retired 34-0 capping it off with wins over duran and pryor in 2005.

kostya could have been the greatest!

[BennyST]

And Calzaghe has the better resume.

That's very arguable. Over the course of both guys careers I would say that Tszyu fought the much better opposition. That's my opinion anyway.

Calzaghe: Jones, Hopkins, Eubank, Kessler, Lacy, Reid etc.

Tszyu: Chavez, Judah, Mitchell, Gonzales, R. Mayweather, Ruelas, Bramble, LaPorte, Leija, Grove, Rodriguez etc.

Oh yeah, and Calzaghe and Tszyu had the exact same amount of time at the top as champion. Tszyu was a champion from 1995 to 2005 and Calzaghe was champion from 1997 to 2007. That is of course not including his fight with Hopkins which was not actually for any title at all. Well, apart from the Ring 'title' but I don't know if that counts. Sort of I guess.

[Left Hook Tua]

D3adbrain , i'm waiting.

list joe calzaghe's TOP 10 biggest fights.

shouldn't be too hard since he has been boxing for 15 years or so.

[Left Hook Tua]

That's very arguable. Over the course of both guys careers I would say that Tszyu fought the much better opposition. That's my opinion anyway.

Calzaghe: Jones, Hopkins, Eubank, Kessler, Lacy, Reid etc.

Tszyu: Chavez, Judah, Mitchell, Gonzales, R. Mayweather, Ruelas, Bramble, LaPorte, Leija, Grove, Rodriguez etc.

wasn't laporte like his 4th fight or something?

i know laporte wasn't a natural 140 guy and a bit shopworn but to take on a vet like that when you're barely starting out is very impressive.

if only 140 was a deeper division.