Why is Mayweathers resume so thin compared to other fighters in the last 15 years ?

[Chr0nic]

A resume is such a flimsey way by itself to judge a fighter, they are so much more then what their resume says~.

You do not hire prespective employees based on just a resumes, you only hire people after interviews and deterimining if what the resumes is saying is accurate. I view boxing resumes the same way, they are a good way to start, but are not the be all and end all~.

right, but a good resume is important, cuz even tho you may look absoloutly out of this world, facing good opposition is PROVING how good your realy are. Putting your mettle to the test

[The Gambler1981]

right, but a good resume is important, cuz even tho you may look absoloutly out of this world, facing good opposition is PROVING how good your realy are. Putting your mettle to the test

Like I said it is a good place to start, but is not the be all and end all. If all you know is a fighters resume, you basically do not know **** about them (imo). So therefore it is not a true meassure of a fighter (it can be used to meassure a fighter to a certain extent, but by itself it paints only an incomplete picture).

[Roger Mellie]

right, but a good resume is important, cuz even tho you may look absoloutly out of this world, facing good opposition is PROVING how good your realy are. Putting your mettle to the test

Absoloutly? and you have the nerve to have a pop about my spelling! LMAO

[Chr0nic]

Like I said it is a good place to start, but is not the be all and end all. If all you know is a fighters resume, you basically do not know **** about them (imo). So therefore it is not a true meassure of a fighter (it can be used to meassure a fighter to a certain extent, but by itself it paints only an imcomplete picture).

true true......

[Roger Mellie]

true true......

Yeah,true,its aboloutly rhgit.............mongggggggggggggg!

[JAB5239]

A resume is such a flimsey way by itself to judge a fighter, they are so much more then what their resume says~.

You do not hire prespective employees based on just a resumes, you only hire people after interviews and deterimining if what the resumes is saying is accurate. I view boxing resumes the same way, they are a good way to start, but are not the be all and end all~.

I would never call a resume the end all when judging a fighter. It is however, in my opinion, the best way to judge a fighters career. You can't determine how skilled one fighter is compared to another without looking and comparing resumes, its impossible to accurately do so with out looking at who said fighters actually fought.

Mayweather is an undoubtedly a supremely gifted fighter. Is he more gifted than say Pernell Whitaker? Who knows. What we do know is that he didn't beat better fighters. How about Ray Leonard or Duran? It all comes down to who you beat when determining how great you were or were not. Not the end all, but certainly the bottom line.

[Chr0nic]

Yeah,true,its aboloutly rhgit.............mongggggggggggggg!

go cry me a river

[The Gambler1981]

I would never call a resume the end all when judging a fighter. It is however, in my opinion, the best way to judge a fighters career. You can't determine how skilled one fighter is compared to another without looking and comparing resumes, its impossible to accurately do so with out looking at who said fighters actually fought.

Mayweather is an undoubtedly a supremely gifted fighter. Is he more gifted than say Pernell Whitaker? Who knows. What we do know is that he didn't beat better fighters. How about Ray Leonard or Duran? It all comes down to who you beat when determining how great you were or were not. Not the end all, but certainly the bottom line.

Boiling a fighter down to just a resume is an over simlified view of their career. I consider it poor analysis of ones career, it is a good start but nothing like a bottom line (bottom line being an accounting term that means everything is accounted for~).

If that is the only argument you have, I am not swayed~.

[Roger Mellie]

go cry me a river

FFS! You have only been back 2 seconds and you have already managed to pwn yourself! Give yourself a big clap m-m-mm-mm-meg-g-g-ga-dude!

[JAB5239]

Boiling a fighter down to just a resume is an over simlified view of their career. I consider it poor analysis of ones career, it is a good start but nothing like a bottom line (bottom line being an accounting term that means everything is accounted for~).

If that is the only argument you have, I am not swayed~.

Who said about "boiling a fighter down to JUST a resume"? Im arguing that it is the most important factor when judging a fighters career, not the only one.

Swayed or not swayed I don't here you making an argument against my rationalization, only putting it down.