Antonio Margarito on Mexico's All-Time list?

[MANGLER]

He was just startin to get rollin before he got busted in the SSM fight. He ain't done enuf to be one of the greats.

[DaTrooth]

Rosario sucks, just because he lost to Julio Casar Chavez, doesnt mean he should be put on the list......


by the way, you know more about PR boxing.......

This shows how ****** you are. YOu have camacho as your #5 ATG for puerto rico yet rosario lost a very close decision to camacho. One judge had him winning and many others felt rosario won as well. Rosario defeate the great mexican fighter Ramirez and frankie randell. He also knocked out a fighter that lasted like 7 rounds with arguello and rosario knocked him out in 1 round. YOu obviously don't know **** about what you talk about. Dam kid!

[IwatchBoxing]

here it is again from the ashes

This shows how ****** you are. YOu have camacho as your #5 ATG for puerto rico yet rosario lost a very close decision to camacho. One judge had him winning and many others felt rosario won as well. Rosario defeate the great mexican fighter Ramirez and frankie randell. He also knocked out a fighter that lasted like 7 rounds with arguello and rosario knocked him out in 1 round. YOu obviously don't know **** about what you talk about. Dam kid!

So, what?? put me asleep there, Rosario did nothing, oh but he knocked a bum out LOL I dont even have Camacho at #5 ....

1. Carlos Ortiz - one of the best Lightweights OAT
2. Wilfredo Gomez -the best 122 pounder OAT
3. Wilfred Benitez - Most of the best defensive fighters
4. Jose Basora - deafeated Jake lamotta and sugar ray Robinson
5. Pedro Montanez - one of the best fighters to never hold a belt
6. Jose Torres - Light Heaveyweight
7. Sixto escobar - 1st champion
8. Felix Trinidad
9. Carlos De Leon - one of the best Cruiserweights
10. juan laporte - has questionable loses to Sanchez and Chavez
11. Esteban de Jesus - defeated Roberto Duran
12. Hector Camacho
13. Alfredo Escalera
14. Miguel Cotto
15. Ivan Calderon
16. Juan Manuel Lopez

[TheGreatA]

Rosario is a hall of famer who has more than a couple of very good wins (Ramirez, Randall, Bramble, Nazario, Davis Jr, Garza, Viruet, etc.), a 4 time title holder. He deserves a spot on the list.

[IwatchBoxing]

Rosario is a hall of famer who has more than a couple of very good wins (Ramirez, Randall, Bramble, Nazario, Davis Jr, Garza, Viruet, etc.), a 4 time title holder. He deserves a spot on the list.

to make a top ten list you dont even need him or Camacho...

[IwatchBoxing]

far worst list than mine (no Camacho or edwin noobs)

http://www.***********.com/1433-top-...-fighters.html

if a boxer from your island beat Jake Lamotta and drew with Sugar Ray Robinson, wouldnt you have made a parade for him?? HMM...

[TheGreatA]

far worst list than mine (no Camacho or edwin noobs)

http://www.***********.com/1433-top-...-fighters.html

if a boxer from your island beat Jake Lamotta and drew with Sugar Ray Robinson, wouldnt you have made a parade for him?? HMM...

Basora was also knocked out in 55 seconds by Ray Robinson and stopped by LaMotta.

Rosario and Serrano are on that list by the way.

[IwatchBoxing]

Basora was also knocked out in 55 seconds by Ray Robinson and stopped by LaMotta.

Rosario and Serrano are on that list by the way.

Yes, they are, both heres a secert, Rosario was knocked out in 4 rounds by someone far less than the greatest boxer ever, and being stopped by Lamotta in 9 after beating him twice, does not define your greatness, heres the list

Saddo boxing's top 12 a boxing website
1. wilfred Benitez
2. esteban de jesus
3. sixto escobar
4. wilfredo gomez
5. juan laporte
6. john john molina
7.carlos ortiz
8. edwin rasorio
9. samuel serrano
10. jose torres
11. felix trinidad
12. wilfredo vasquez

[DaTrooth]

Basora was also knocked out in 55 seconds by Ray Robinson and stopped by LaMotta.

Rosario and Serrano are on that list by the way.

manchine stop this guy obviously is not that smart. It's funny to think someone can make an all time puerto rican list and leave out serrano and rosario especially considering rasario is good enough for boxings hall of fame but not good enough to make puerto's atg list

[TheGreatA]

Yes, they are, both heres a secert, Rosario was knocked out in 4 rounds by someone far less than the greatest boxer ever, and being stopped by Lamotta in 9 after beating him twice, does not define your greatness, heres the list

Saddo boxing's top 12 a boxing website
1. wilfred Benitez
2. esteban de jesus
3. sixto escobar
4. wilfredo gomez
5. juan laporte
6. john john molina
7.carlos ortiz
8. edwin rasorio
9. samuel serrano
10. jose torres
11. felix trinidad
12. wilfredo vasquez

Basora was also beaten by a lot of boxers other than Robinson and LaMotta...

He did have great moments during his career but it's not as if he bested Robinson or LaMotta, he lost the series to both of them (which is no shame since they were great fighters).

I would place him on my list but everyone's record can be picked apart just as you are picking apart the resumes of Rosario, Camacho and Serrano. They were accomplished fighters.