If Manny Pacquiao Beats Hatton, Mayweather, & Cotto = Fighter of the Decade?

[S.G.]

If that happened, all convincingly.

He'd be top 5 atg, easily.

none of this top 10/20 ****. TOP 5 ATG.

Nah...... not ability-wise nor resume-wise does he trump the top 10

[crold1]

Nah...... not ability-wise nor resume-wise does he trump the top 10

His resume would stand with anyones, ever, and he'd have a title accomplishment unlike anything ever seen in the history of Boxing. Not saying he will do it, but if he did it would say tons about his ability.

[hammerhiem]

Nah...... not ability-wise nor resume-wise does he trump the top 10

would be very hard for a Modern fighter with the number of fighters and amount of avoidance that happens (Not really something you can accuse Pac off to any extent) to break top 10.

[hammerhiem]

His resume would stand with anyones, ever, and he'd have a title accomplishment unlike anything ever seen in the history of Boxing. Not saying he will do it, but if he did it would say tons about his ability.

No, it really doesn't, Sorry.

[-----------]

Nah...... not ability-wise nor resume-wise does he trump the top 10

Ability - hard to tell.

Resume - Are you ****ing kidding me?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

“I love beating the odds. If there weren’t any upsets in the world, it would be a boring place."

- Freddie Roach

I agree, but you know I was being realistic. Pacman is a hell of a fighter, but except for Hatton(That he will KO for Sure), I dont think he can beat PBF or Cotto!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[crold1]

No, it really doesn't, Sorry.

Why because he didn't fought 178 No Decisions in the twenties? Most have Duran in their top ten all time; Manny's resume would sit right there with Duran and he'd be the first fighter in history to go from 112 to 140 winning World titles when the closest anyone ever came was LaBarba almost clipping Chocolate at 30. While I don't think much of the win itself because of where Oscar was, no former Flyweight champ has ever beaten a former Welter champ at welter. You weight the restraints of his era against what he got done, and where, and he stands with anyone IF he pulled this off.

He won't.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Why because he didn't fought 178 No Decisions in the twenties? Most have Duran in their top ten all time; Manny's resume would sit right there with Duran and he'd be the first fighter in history to go from 112 to 140 winning World titles when the closest anyone ever came was LaBarba almost clipping Chocolate at 30. While I don't think much of the win itself because of where Oscar was, no former Flyweight champ has ever beaten a former Welter champ at welter. You weight the restraints of his era against what he got done, and where, and he stands with anyone IF he pulled this off.

He won't.

are you the writer Cliff Rold?

[crold1]

are you the writer Cliff Rold?

Yes that's me. Were you just wondering?

[The Great Shark]

Yeah, obviously, conquering the weight class would make him greater than he already is.