If Manny Pacquiao Beats Hatton, Mayweather, & Cotto = Fighter of the Decade?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Yes that's me. Were you just wondering?

yep...that's all...i've read your write ups...good to see you on the boards

[crold1]

yep...that's all...i've read your write ups...good to see you on the boards

A lot of the writers are. Jake, Greisman and even senor Reeno.

[Fights]

its gonna be a sad day when he retires

We will miss him.

[PrtyBoyDlicious]

Not to hug Pac's nut.. but Pac already beaten 4 sure fire HOFers..Morales, Barrera, Marquez and ODLH...he's already an ATG...

he doesn't need to beat Hatton, Cotto or PBF to be an ATG...the first two are not even HOF candidate...

[crold1]

Not to hug Pac's nut.. but Pac already beaten 4 sure fire HOFers..Morales, Barrera, Marquez and ODLH...he's already an ATG...

he doesn't need to beat Hatton, Cotto or PBF to be an ATG...the first two are not even HOF candidate...

Of course. No one's even arguing that. This about tiers of ATG and there are higher tiers he can climb to.

[PrtyBoyDlicious]

Of course. No one's even arguing that. This about tiers of ATG and there are higher tiers he can climb to.

tiers?

Lets move forward a bit, so, who does Pac needs to beat at what weight to be considered the fighter of the century?

[crold1]

tiers?

Lets move forward a bit, so, who does Pac needs to beat at what weight to be considered the fighter of the century?

yes, tiers is a good word for it; maybe startification. Ray Robinson and Alexis Arguello are both ATG's, but Robinson would be considered a full step up. As to the end of the century...who the hell knows?

[PrtyBoyDlicious]

yes, tiers is a good word for it; maybe startification. Ray Robinson and Alexis Arguello are both ATG's, but Robinson would be considered a full step up. As to the end of the century...who the hell knows?

For dicussion sakes, lets say year 1 of 100 years starts in 1910, who do you think Pac needs to fight and beat in 2 years time to be considered ATG for the past 100 years?

[crold1]

For dicussion sakes, lets say year 1 of 100 years starts in 1910, who do you think Pac needs to fight and beat in 2 years time to be considered ATG for the past 100 years?

If you mean to be the very best, numero uno? He's not better than Ray Robinson accomplishments or not so nothing.

[PrtyBoyDlicious]

If you mean to be the very best, numero uno? He's not better than Ray Robinson accomplishments or not so nothing.

so, even if pac beaten for example cotto, pbf, mosley, marg and paul williams, he still cannot equal or surpass robinson's accomplishments?