Better Resume: James Toney Vs Roy Jones Jr

[The Gunner]

Roy has also been brutaly KO'd twice that should be factored into this too.

[THE REED]

im leavin for now... jus so u know im not duckin responses

[KostyaTszyu44]

toney, pretty clearly too

[THE REED]

Roy has also been brutaly KO'd twice that should be factored into this too.

there two completely different resumes, who accomplished different things in there careers, its hard to compare them, but of course you would have to take his losses into consideration, as long as u take toneys...

[The Gunner]

He was never blown out though, never stopped... im not touting Malinga as a "great" fighter... but he was a very good fighter, and could hold his own in the ring.... and roy completely smashed him.

He's been blew out a few times dude and ive saw him schooled a few times too.

He was B-level at best.

[KostyaTszyu44]

ill give credit to roy though, he was the only man to ever dominate james toney

toney has had other losses, but they were all close, the only unquestionable loss he suffered was at the hands of roy

[Steak]

Ltes also take note, that after that fight, Bernard didnt lose a fight.. for about 12 years... he couldnt of been THAT bad... Roy also progessed immensly after that fight as well...

eh. Im not saying that Bernard was a bad fighter at that point...but he did struggle with Mercado I think about 2 years later, and I personally thought it took about 3 or 4 years for Hopkins to enter his prime after the Jones fight, starting around the Glen Johnson win.

....but that version of Bernard would probebly have lost decisively to prime Nunn and near prime McCallum

speaking of guys roy smashed, he really did a number on Sosa, and he was supposed to be an incredibly durable fighter. Roys domination has to give him extra points, although at the same time its very unlikely that he would have dominated guys like prime Nunn.(he did have trouble for a while with Harding, who was a comparable fighter)

[Steak]

He's been blew out a few times dude and ive saw him schooled a few times too.

He was B-level at best.

well, Maligna was at least as good as someone like Robin Reid...maybe Im getting mixed up, but Im pretty sure Maligna beat him to become champ.

[THE REED]

He's been blew out a few times dude and ive saw him schooled a few times too.

He was B-level at best.

at the time roy fought him malinga had suffered mostly UD and MD losses, he was never stopped and roy stopped him in 6...

anyways, i dont thikn malinga should be the focal point of this thread...

i gata go tho! been on here all day!

see ya guys

[THE REED]

ill give credit to roy though, he was the only man to ever dominate james toney

toney has had other losses, but they were all close, the only unquestionable loss he suffered was at the hands of roy

thatgoes for bernard as well