Better Resume: James Toney Vs Roy Jones Jr

[Dynamite Kid]

Of course, your right. Both fighters loses have to be took into consideration.

It can be argued that Toney only has one legit loss on his record and that was to Roy.

Roys been brutaly KO'd twice and lost two very clear decisions too.

Ive got Toneys career set and i have to say i think he only lost two fights. The fight with Roy and one of the Peter fights.

I had him losing to Oquendo too but thats went down as a win for him.

That depends on if you think he beat Tiberi,Rahman 1,McCallum 1 & 2, Griffin 1 & 2,Peter 1 & 2.

I thought he lost majority of those fights he lost clearly to Drake Thadzi a journeyman and he was in shape for that apparently.

[RAESAAD]

toney has one of the worst resumes in boxing, this is an embaressing thread and a disgrace to roy jones jr.

toney p4p best bum beater.

I'm shocked by this post and the results of the poll to be perfectly frank.

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

hopkins, tarver, toney, ruiz > holyfield, jirov, barkley, mccallum

toney beat ruiz too although it was changed to a NC of course..but he fought ruiz and beat his ass during the fight.

but to answer your question, i say roy.