Is Floyd Mayweather jr an ATG?

[hammerhiem]

i don't have spinks nor holyfield in my atg list. the 175 and 190 divisions i don't rate too highly in the 80's. just my opinion though.

Spinks was a brainfart moment it should have been Holmes.

[pbftxrs316]

of course he is rather you like it or not...he retired p4p#1- 6 titles in 5 division..and undefeated....

in 10 years to add to this. let ther haters hate, that's what we have them for.

[Floydmayweather]

I think he is but if he is not a win over Pacman and a climb back to the top of the sport would make him an all time great. He needs another big win or two just to show everyone he can do it. He should fight Marquez and then Pac. And then out. A fight against the Cotto/Margarito would be nice but i think they are just too big. He could still win but in a boring fashion.

[larryx]

floyds resume is no better and no worse then calzaghes

take your biased shades off man..your hate for floyd is sickening

[AKATheMack]

If wew were voting based on potential and talent Id say yes, but he hasnt fought enough top guys to rate him based on performance. He also hasnt cleaned out any divisions he jumped around a lot without really establishing as the best. If he had continued to fight at 130-135 and beat everybody which I believe he could have done I would say yes. But retiring when there were several huge fights that could have been made is a questionable decision for someone who is an ATG. Hes a good fighter but hes no SRL

[S A M U R A I]

take your biased shades off man..your hate for floyd is sickening

Larry, it goes both ways. Some might say your biased love for Floydy boy is sickening.

Just sayin.



100% free webcam site! | Awesome chicks and it is absolutely free! | Watch free live sex cam - easy as 1-2-3

[ACHlLLES]

If we were voting based on potential and talent Id say yes, but he hasnt fought enough top guys to rate him based on performance. He also hasnt cleaned out any divisions he jumped around a lot without really establishing as the best. If he had continued to fight at 130-135 and beat everybody which I believe he could have done I would say yes. But retiring when there were several huge fights that could have been made is a questionable decision for someone who is an ATG. Hes a good fighter but hes no SRL

This post earned my green karma.

[AKATheMack]

Larry, it goes both ways. Some might say your biased love for Floydy boy is sickening.

Just sayin.

I say it is, but I say the blind hate is sickening also.

[El Dominicano]

Damn 16 people are ******

[AKATheMack]

This post earned my green karma.

Appreciated