Is Floyd Mayweather jr an ATG?

[crold1]

Floyd Mayweather can make a case as the GOAT at 130 lbs. That's ATG enough because that debate features Alexis, Saddler and...yeah, that's about it.

[The Gambler1981]

He is in the top 99.95% of boxers in history ( 5 out of 10,000 or so are better). That pretty ATG if you ask me.

[crold1]

He is in the top 99.95% of boxers in history ( 5 out of 10,000 or so are better). That pretty ATG if you ask me.

You haven't seen 99.95% of Boxers in history to make the statement...and well more than five were not only better but significantly better AND greater.

[The Gambler1981]

You haven't seen 99.95% of Boxers in history to make the statement...and well more than five were not only better but significantly better AND greater.

It is a generalization and more then 10,000 people have boxed in history. Do the math please. Yes you are right though there are many better.

[Flawless.]

Left Hook Tua is a hypocrite, he ranks Kostya and Tito ATG but not Mayweather

[crold1]

Left Hook Tua is a hypocrite, he ranks Kostya and Tito ATG but not Mayweather

Tszyu is one of the most overrated fighters in my lifetime. His resume doesn't sniff Mayweather's. Tito's sort of does, but Tito wasn't that much better than Corrales or Castillo.

[KostyaTszyu44]

of course he is

6 titles in 5 weight classes ,undefeated, incredible skills

wins over DLH, hatton, castillo, corrales, hernandez, gatti, judah, baldomir and mitchell

the ones in bold are shoo in future HoFers, hatton may or may not be depending on how he goes in his next couple of fights but will probably end up there

how is he not an ATG???

[KostyaTszyu44]

Left Hook Tua is a hypocrite, he ranks Kostya and Tito ATG but not Mayweather

true that

i love kostya but mayweather is a much better fighter

i was never really a big tito fan but hes not as good as floyd either

[mishka80]

yes he is.

[KostyaTszyu44]

FFS reppinDubK

what does floyd hve to do to be an ATG???? kick your ass???