Is Oscar De La Hoya an all-time great?

[Mr. Fantastic]

Floyd mainly only deserves credit for the DLH win because of the size disadvantage. Other than that, I didn't think much of it at all.

I don't think much of the Hopkins win over DLH. It helped somewhat that it was a catchweight of 158, and Hopkins even went to 156, but it is more name value than a actual great quality win for Hopkins.

Isn't that a little bit hypocritical that someone gets credit(Hopkins,Floyd) but not DLH for beating 2 greats in Whitaker & Chavez??? Floyd was P4P #1 in the world, he was the favorite to win against the "faded" Oscar.

Apart from Tito....what is BHop's greatest win???? The DLH/Bhop fight is like Hatton moving up in weight against a natural welter in Margarito.

[JAB5239]

Who beat the better prime fighters, Winky or Oscar? this is your rebuttal?

Oscar did, no doubt about it. Care to debate it?

[lparm]

Oscar did, no doubt about it. Care to debate it?

I forgot Vargas and Quartey are more Hall worthy than Mosley lol Jabbo....

[JAB5239]

I forgot Vargas and Quartey are more Hall worthy than Mosley lol Jabbo....

By your sarcasm I'll take that as a no, you don't want to debate it. Smart move.

[lparm]

By your sarcasm I'll take that as a no, you don't want to debate it. Smart move.

This thread is dead so come along little sheep follow me to another one.

[Mr. Fantastic]

By your sarcasm I'll take that as a no, you don't want to debate it. Smart move.

He has a habit of flipping **** dude. When he knows the answer he comes back at you with more questions instead of answering.

[JAB5239]

This thread is dead so come along little sheep follow me to another one.

In other words, "Jab, please stop mopping the floor with me, I quit". Lol, figures.

[lparm]

In other words, "Jab, please stop mopping the floor with me, I quit". Lol, figures.

Yes, jabbo stop mopping the floor with your DLH has never beaten a prime great in his era excuses or he's not even top 10 p4p in his era examples. You sure got me kid lol

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=226475

[We want Floyd]

Does Joto belong with Archie Moore, Muhammad Ali, Leonard, Duran, Sugar Ray Robinson, Marvin Hagler ?

There's is a right and wrong answer to this.

[JAB5239]

He has a habit of flipping **** dude. When he knows the answer he comes back at you with more questions instead of answering.

I've been destroying Leons sorry opinions for a few years now. I know exactly how he operates, my man. I've watched him twist things and flat out lie on a variety of subjects. Once he's backed into a corner and can't lie or twist anymore he'll start name calling and flaming, hence his last post directed to me. Peace.