Is Calzaghe the Greatest of All Time?

[miron_lang]

Hit it up your majesty.

You are green now with 1 karma hit

[withoutthee]

I have this special power. Do you want to be green?

Thank you very much.

[tommy boo boxer]

Isn't he the guy who got done for Fraud or something?

no hes the one thats getting done for illegal hand wraps

[Libido Sanchez]

Is Calzaghe the Greatest Of All Time?

No, Apollo Creed is. (RIP Champ)

Some might wonder why I would bring up Carl Weather's alter ego. This is a thread about make believe, right?

[SonOfCuba]

what an idiot

[Oasis_Lad]

Pretty much, yes.

[a-raines21]

no, he didnt. 51-0. you lose. which doesnt make him near the best ever, but hey, you brought up these statistics in the first place...

the fact that you put Hearns, Ez Charles, Moore below Calzaghe and Marciano makes my head explode.

the fact that your overlooking is he aint 46-0 in america...... roy jones was 46-1, and that one loss was by dq......... and his dominance was obvious....joe retired instead of taking the last challenge out there......... shows cowardice.... something that the greatest of all time shouldn't have

[andrewcuff]

Is Calzaghe the Greatest of All Time? There are a number threads now dancing around this question. So let's just get to it.

As much as I like watching him, no, not by a long way.

Furthermore, Cal defeated two solid ATGs (Bernard Hopkins and Roy Jones, Jr.) while in his mid 30s

The Roy Jones he beat is not the great Roy Jones of years gone by. Watch his fight against Toney then compare it to the fight against Calzaghe. Not the same boxer.

He's the only major boxer I know of that is ambidextrous (both right and left handed) and this commonly results in a state of confusion that hampers the effectiveness and confidence of his opponents.

Marvin Hagler?

Few in history have been as elusive as Calzaghe and also possessed of a granite chin. Ali comes to mind, but not many others.

Yes I'm sure Pernell Whitaker is very jealous.


I'm a Welsh Calzaghe fan, but this post is absolute tripe.

[andrewcuff]

joe retired instead of taking the last challenge out there......... shows cowardice.... something that the greatest of all time shouldn't have

And you're a Mayweather fan?

[Doctor_Tenma]

Lets be real here, Calzaghe beat both RJJ and B-Hop, Calzaghe is the GOAT.