Final answer. Chad Dawson beats Calzaghe

[KILLA RIGHT]

U cant win that way cause glen and tarver ko'd roy but b hop lost to joe who beat tarver..Either way no matter what joe does he's gonna get 0 credit from haters

[.Mik.]

U cant win that way cause glen and tarver ko'd roy but b hop lost to joe who beat tarver..Either way no matter what joe does he's gonna get 0 credit from haters

And the one that has lost to none of them...is Joe.

[The Monk]

I really would like to see this fight. I would just about give the edge to Calzaghe, but i'm a big fan of Chad and think he is going to be the upper echelons of the p4p list within the next few years.

I think this fight would be a good move for Joe, if he wins he'll solidify himself as one of the best fighters of the modern era and if he loses he has already achieved so much. I also think this fight should be in the States and not a farewell fight in Cardiff. I do think he should have a fairwell fight after though, perhaps against Winky.

Calzaghe's biggest wins were against former 154-160lbers .

Dawson's biggest wins were against 175lbers.

Which former 154lber was Joe's big win then? Try to not make yourself look like an idiot again.

[KILLA RIGHT]

And the one that has lost to none of them...is Joe.

but he never fought glen tarver and dawson..If we go that way we will never figure it out.But joe is far the truth an recognize haters...I love joe haters i think it burns them inside waiting for someone to beat him haha

[daggum]

I really would like to see this fight. I would just about give the edge to Calzaghe, but i'm a big fan of Chad and think he is going to be the upper echelons of the p4p list within the next few years.

I think this fight would be a good move for Joe, if he wins he'll solidify himself as one of the best fighters of the modern era and if he loses he has already achieved so much. I also think this fight should be in the States and not a farewell fight in Cardiff. I do think he should have a fairwell fight after though, perhaps against Winky.



Which former 154lber was Joe's big win then? Try to not make yourself look like an idiot again.

jones and kessler started at 154. why is joe fighting blown up junior middles anyway? fraud exposed

[The Monk]

jones and kessler started at 154. why is joe fighting blown up junior middles anyway? fraud exposed

"Started" at 154 doesn't mean ****. They both made their name in higher divisions. Joe beat them at their natural weight and neither of them were "blown up" you ******.

How about Johnson and Harding? Are they "blown up" as well because they started at lower divisons? Stop talking out your arse and then maybe people will take you seriously.

[.Mik.]

but he never fought glen tarver and dawson..If we go that way we will never figure it out.But joe is far the truth an recognize haters...I love joe haters i think it burns them inside waiting for someone to beat him haha

Yeah, but nor did they fight him and nor did they beat him. The only universal truth is that out of the 5, Calzaghe is the only one that has fought any of the others and leaves with an undefeated record.

[Sweet Pea 50]

I would love to see this fight happen. I don't think it is going to, though. Dawson really isn't that big of a name. Way too high risk, with not enough reward for Zags.

[Pullcounter]

i think calz will beat dawson by s/d or u/d, but that doesn't mean he should duck dawson. that's why i voted for dawson by ko so that people wouldn't use this poll to justify calz ducking dawson.

[Kris Silver]

Workrate - Calzaghe
Power - Dawson
Handspeed - Calzaghe
Heart - Calzaghe
Chin - Calzaghe
Experience - Calzaghe
Stamina - Calzaghe

Calzaghe by UD

Nicely outlined.

Does anyone actually argue with this?

I'd be intrigued because if they don't how does Dawson beat him?

If they do, how exactly is Dawson better in said area?