Who has the better resume at 130? Floyd Mayweather or Manny Pacquaio?

[wmute]

I believe they'd both beat each other's rosters just as easily but in different fashion. The real question is how much better would Pac have been with the same 2nd gen pedigree and amateur training as floyd.

I would be curious to see Pac easily avoiding Corrales right hand long enough to work him...

[wmute]

I would be all over "testing" it first, if only I could reach..........

lol... i guess

[wmute]

Oh ok. agreed. Even if it was Pac's umpteenth weight class Mayweather still edges him out because of the morales loss alone.

yeah i dot know to me it's more than those guys were not 130ers.

To push it very much to the extreme (in weight difference and ranking of opponent). It's like if Ruiz had beaten Jones and Toney, would that make any statement on how good of a heavy he was?

[shadeyfizzle]

I would be curious to see Pac easily avoiding Corrales right hand long enough to work him...

You know what my statement really implied smartass. I would also be curious to see Floyd knock out Morales

[El Dominicano]

yeah i dot know to me it's more than those guys were not 130ers.

To push it very much to the extreme (in weight difference and ranking of opponent). It's like if Ruiz had beaten Jones and Toney, would that make any statement on how good of a heavy he was?

That hurtz, I see what your sayin but I think you over exaggerated a lil

[shadeyfizzle]

yeah i dot know to me it's more than those guys were not 130ers.

To push it very much to the extreme (in weight difference and ranking of opponent). It's like if Ruiz had beaten Jones and Toney, would that make any statement on how good of a heavy he was?

I see what you're saying but Morales was a legit 130 champ and regarded far higher than any other titlist the division had at the time who were real 130ers. Its not necessarily Barrera, Morales, Pac or Marquez's fault they had to keep fighting each other. They just had to because they were really the best of the division

[Silencers]

On paper Pacquiao has the better resume but then you could argue that Barrera and Morales were past their primes and Larios didn't belong at 130, Mayweather fought those guys in their primes apart from Hernandez.

[Fox McCloud]

Quit yapping and PM me back *****.

Clearly I will... just not tonight. I've had a rough day and it is late...

Plus, I'm nutting myself over Morales's performance against Paulie Ayala.

I just jumped on to make a thread about how incredible Morales is fighting in this fight.

[JoartCC]

floyd was the greatest superfeather of all time.

There is nothing in Gayweather's resume which can top wins over legends like Barrera and Morales...

Of course if you count wins over Judah, Gatti, Corley, etc...

You're an idiot gayweather fan.

[Allucard]

manny was at 130 during a better time

floyd kinda had no option but to move up....he was leaps and bounds above anyone at 130

so i guess pac

floyd was more impressive tho

Best answer i must say. But as a fan i still had to vote Floyd