Joe Calzaghe Is Not A Light Heavyweight Champion

[T-97]

I didn't mean you

I know, I was just agreeing with you

[Pugilistic™]

He got the win over Hopkins rewarding him the ring mag light heavyweight title.

[THE REED]

how can you people debate this so early in the morning, i cant open my god damn eyes...

[Stickman]

Youre not telling me anything I dont know, fighting at the catchweight they fought and not 175 meant Hop still had to cut muscle to get there and not come in at 175.

Ok, yeah...you're an idiot.

A "catchweight" would've been something both fighters agreed upon that was either over 175, or under 168, and it wouldn't have involved a LH title.

Someone already told you to shut the **** up if you don't know what you're talking about. Didn't you read that post?

[THE REED]

Ok, yeah...you're an idiot.

A "catchweight" would've been something both fighters agreed upon that was either over 175, or under 168, and it wouldn't have involved a LH title.

Someone already told you to shut the **** up if you don't know what you're talking about. Didn't you read that post?

no actually you can have a catchweight of 170, still for the LHW title...

pretty strong words there buddy

[T-97]

how can you people debate this so early in the morning, i cant open my god damn eyes...

It's 2PM here

Ok, yeah...you're an idiot.

A "catchweight" would've been something both fighters agreed upon that was either over 175, or under 168, and it wouldn't have involved a LH title.

Someone already told you to shut the **** up if you don't know what you're talking about. Didn't you read that post?

We found out what he meant, He had the Winky Wright fight and Calzaghe fights confused. The Winky fight was at 170, so I think that's what he was thinking of

[Left Hook Tua]

It's 2PM here



We found out what he meant, He had the Winky Wright fight and Calzaghe fights confused. The Winky fight was at 170, so I think that's what he was thinking of

i always thought winky and joe looked alike.

are they related?

[Pugilistic™]

i always thought winky and joe looked alike.

are they related?

[MELLY-MEL...]

i always thought winky and joe looked alike.

are they related?

[bsrizpac]

Joe beat Hop at a catchweight, lets not forget this and not 175. Gary Shaw said something very important during the Dawson press conference that made alot of sense and there is a reason why we have weight divisions. If Floyd had fought Gatti at 135 and won, many would have said well Floyd beat him at 135 and not 140 and many would still wonder what would happen at 140, like many still wonder what would happen at 140 between Floyd and Hatton. Make no mistake Joe Calzaghe is only a 175 lb champ on paper and nothing more.